Transcripción
Emprender en CUATRO SECTORES y vivir en CUATRO CONTINENTES | Reby y Two | Podcast #299 — vídeo y transcripción
Hoy hablamos con Kiran Thomas, fundador de Reby y Two. Kiran ha vivido en cuatro continentes y ha emprendido en cuatro sectores distintos.
Título
Emprender en CUATRO SECTORES y vivir en CUATRO CONTINENTES | Reby y Two | Podcast #299 — vídeo y transcripción
Resumen
Hoy hablamos con Kiran Thomas, fundador de Reby y Two. Kiran ha vivido en cuatro continentes y ha emprendido en cuatro sectores distintos.
Puntos clave
- did you meet with kolau not directly but with the rest of her team and this was quite a challenge because we moved ahead without let's say their blessing there were people who were fined yet really yeah there are people who find she's like as a Founder which is hard enough then again fighting against the police like on top of everything fighting against the market and fighting against the place it was challenging uh to say the least and then how did what happened with Robbie yeah exactly between the news it was recently in the news yeah so it's um it's still in in litigation so in the US in the US is [Music] engagement [Music] [Music] bienvenido [Music] daily welcome everybody I'm Bernard Ferrero today I'm with Jordan Romero how are you Jersey very good I'm with Kiran Thomas how are you kidding doing well thanks Kiran is a consultant initially then executive then entrepreneur yeah there was a period in between where it was also part of the founding team of uh which is today latam's let's say top five uh a general merchandise retailers in the world in the region called Lineo so I was one I was part of the founding team there as well so okay part of the journey okay so in in entrepreneurship you've participated in projects around Mobility with Rabbi yeah fintech with two and e-commerce with linear and e-commerce and you are from India originally that's correct so yeah my roots are there I was born and raised there uh so my formative years were living were there and then I after my education which is engineering degree in computer science I immigrated to the United States where I started working and got acquainted with what in the US so most of my uh life in the US was based in Chicago and the Chicago land area a little bit also in in the St Louis Minneapolis area for consulting-based project work somehow life brought you to Barcelona yeah life wrong you live here you're happily living for a while yeah yes near from where we're recording this very close by uh setting down Roots uh literally speaking so my uh uh two I have two kids they both go to school here they're growing up here trilingual obviously they've trilingual so Catalan in school uh Spanish at home with my wife and English with me okay yeah okay we'll talk about Ravi and and two which I think they're very interesting cases but maybe we can follow the chronological order from your Beginnings now as a studying computer science in India maybe you can share with us how how is environment in India to start computer science it's very well known for having great talent in computer science and great universities indeed yeah and and why did you emigrate why did you go out from India sure so um when I was in university uh in the in the late uh 90s early 2000s it was a boom time when you know the I.T Consulting uh phase of of uh of the industry so India was at the time uh servicing most of the West in terms of BPO so business process Outsourcing and so on a lot of Consulting work was coming and being done in the country India was going through a point a time when we were solving problems for the rest of the world rather than internal problems but that's not techno you talk about things more like accounting yeah business classes Insurance yeah call centers and also um development work right so okay a lot of enterprise software uh work was being done income on behalf of large Consulting companies the IBM's Accenture Deloitte so on and so forth so it was quite common to be you know campus recruited by national firms so deloittees Etc start in India and then Branch over get yourself a H1 Visa and go to the America and go to the US that was a difficult path so I had that option that's what I did it was the done thing one you know it just catapulted your career in many ways uh by being able to go there and being sort of let's say trained in a way to go and take on challenges in that market right so was it like your plan from early on like I'm gonna do these four steps so I can go to the US or it just kind of happened they tell you this is It's opportunity it's a bit of both so I had the opportunity and also had you know family there so it made the reason for me to go there a lot more on your ring so yeah so it was a mix of consequences right it was not and it was a time when it was the done thing not to say that doesn't happen now but now there's more of a homegrown industry than that you know is solving big problems in India this and people are finding that a lot more exciting and people stay in the country so it used to be more like the company and the capital is in the US or some other countries and then they hire labor talent in India yeah yeah and what you're saying is now there is more businesses in India hiding their talent locally and just selling their services abroad yeah so now there's a concept of building built in India built for the problems in India and Export those Solutions worldwide right which which makes sense in the past it was solving problems in the west exporting those solutions to third world countries and and developing countries and now there's a reckoning that you know there are real problems to be solved here there's capital in those markets of course some Capital comes from from from outside the country and this is much stronger value proposition really I think more than exporting the products is building the internal Market I mean it's a huge Market we're in Spain where 40 something million people and and many many companies are based on focus in the Spanish Market which doesn't make much sense but when you are 1.3 billion people then it makes sense and growing and growing with lots of opportunity to much of the West yeah and and presently with the current Administration uh that is so pro-business uh women of India I mean the current government in India is pro so pro-business uh has put a lot of foundational elements in growing the economy right from identity verification to imagine the scale of the challenge right when you're talking about 1.4 1.5 billion people being able to offer them uh you know fintech services like real uh you know there was an unbanked population of what you know 60 70 now that's being reduced uh so there's real value generation in that in in society in India that that's on you know that's coming at an unprecedented rate right so nothing has happened like that in the past so yeah so I studied Computing uh but always had let's say a flare or an interest in pursuing something on the edge between the intersection between business and and and the tax and Tech area so my career in that sense sort of weird off into the analytics area so that's what I first cut my feet doing in in the retail sector working for a large big box retailer called Office Max um in the Chicago Chicago land area so it was instrumental in their post merger integration structure yeah Wilson you know experience especially at scale so we're talking about uh at the time the operations were somewhere in the range of about 2000 stores across the country offline retail and its challenges when it comes to replenishment forecasting purchasing and all of that that led me into uh an opportunity in the career in the retail sector uh in Consulting and Accenture accenture's retail practice I did that for quite a few years and got there was management consulting or Tech Consulting a bit of both again so I was uh so I was I had a very unorthodox experience there as well so I was responsible for the client management of a very large uh retailer called Best Buy and the international expansion it was fantastic it was I was living in Mexico I was living in the UK so they were sending you to different places for this Consulting agreement so it was the same account but I was responsible for a significant piece of uh of the implementation and so on so I spent a better part of three years living out of my suitcase at that point in my life it was great I can't imagine doing that now and decided that you know the next stage of my life would be something in entrepreneurship building on on the experience I had 11 I mean God until that point and then was very fortunate to be make an entry into the e-commerce uh entrepreneurship side of things setting up uh lineal lineupont.com headquartered in Mexico which and expanding it into seven countries across Lata how did linear get started like who comes up with the idea recruits the founding team yeah how is the structure so because it's a bit of an unusual case yeah indeed so it's it's not entrepreneurship as you would as we would do it today where you're starting everything from scratch I mean it's something you can do starting of a boy band right it's kind of you bring together uh key players and you put them together give them Capital exposure and so on and so someone at Rocket said there is an opportunity in e-commerce in latam yeah Samus pitch was do you want to be um I recall this do you want to be uh sleeping under your desk as a banking executive in in in in in Investment Banking or working on the spam filter for for for Google or do you want to be creating the next Amazon in uh in Latin America right so interestingly enough that copy that from Steve Jobs no do you want to keep selling sugar water possibly the guy from Pepsi some iteration okay but nevertheless it's strong it works it struck a very uh strong chord with me so I joined uh Lineo like two two or three months in so I wasn't I didn't get the designation of co-founder so for three months I mean three months it's not so it's not very much but then you know you had you so I met uh so Andreas who is my co-founder at two um he was he was the founder and CEO at um at linear we had a call I was in Mexico he said come join me so I was one of the first let's say executive not executive but one of the leadership team members uh my rolly bald so this was my first experience in e-commerce building out things from scratch to I was what employee number 30 or 40 within the team uh rapidly growing at its peak we were about 1600 people expanding across the region very crazy yeah this is very hard to manage well it's internet model yeah the vertical growth sometimes vertical crash yeah usually many times right so yeah so we we experienced the ups and downs uh it was a great learning experience great incubated model in that you you you build a lot of skills you learn things really fast so yeah just fond memories great experience how far did it go like like before you left how big was linear so linear when I left we were operating in six or seven countries Spanish speaking excellent Marketplace or e-commerce so we pivoted into a Marketplace so initially in the first year it was you know procured by uh model uh in I think year two or one around then we pivoted into a Marketplace model yeah what happened with the company it's a exited so it's sold yeah it's old so Falabella which is a Chilean retailer uh but made an acquisition in 2018.
- if you sort of compared with capital raised and uh relative to let's say valuation valuation yeah it was it was an okay exit for the management team not so great but for growth investors who came in late with liquidation preferences it was good it was a huge lesson yeah that unfortunately had the same in the past right and that's that's that's and you were based where when this was happening I was based in Mexico City and I moved to Barcelona in 2016.
- um so after this experience after the leading experience moved to Barcelona correct yeah but before the acquisition so yeah I was there for four years and then I left um yeah missed the acquisition by like uh 18 months I think it was pretty it was pretty intense from what I hear so at that moment you you met pep Gomez yeah so I know that for for my entry into into Barcelona so I'd known him uh from some of the events in the in the startup space what events maybe people everybody's looking for a co-founder so where did you meet your co-founder uh so he was part of Numa I think it was yeah uh so they their own events their own events it was an incubator or what was yeah so it's part of uh she had to come to the podcast and tell us what Numa was yeah you should have him on of course uh so Numa was um I I believe I don't know if they're still around but that was it was a an offshoot of Mobile World Congress right so it was part of the mobile World fund they had some participation in that uh and it was an incubator uh so Madam at one of the events there had some other connections but the type of event where there's just drinks and some couple of talks or something and you just went there too no actually I had a interesting enough that it reminds me I had another connection to pep just through his um girlfriend at the time he's a friend of uh my wife's sister so it was a random personal connection random personal connection coupled with events and so on getting done uh say it was you know a consequence of the time uh pep broke the the idea creation and so on so he was like pretty clear he wanted to do this uh we met around the time when I was uh leaving prevalia and we were living and then you met this or you met this opportunity and then you left prevalia was it no it was the other way around so I I left pre-value okay and I I started at uh with review so you wanted to start a company or yeah yeah so I wanted to start something the timing was just brilliant like uh uh when I was having my going away party at prevalia I was already Robbie was running so yeah so I remember discussing the welcome party next day no there was a welcome party it was just me and exactly buy Scooters or whatever you do the first day of the company and a week later we were in so it was two two Founders yeah initially uh and then we brought on about six months later two more um again and Christina who basically joined us um to build out the engineering let's say in the China angle of Engineering in China so chief engineer and chief China Hardware it's a hardware yeah Chef hardware and your Chief product or head of problem yeah this product everything else yeah uh I was actually the CEO initially I really so when I started when we started pep was everything to do with regulatory uh legal and fundraising um I thought you were gonna say he didn't do that because it doesn't sound so much fun he did the regulatory legal and fundraising that was bad and I was running all things uh from a serious standpoint okay very soon I realized that this was a hairy animal I wasn't excelling at a job so we game took over from me so Gamers uh who came in as a CEO uh also founder you know you could call him the founder yes so did you call him a Founder yeah yeah okay yeah and what the founder is it Equity certain Equity a significant stake in the business for uh for all uh founders of course yeah we've seen Founders join Founders joint companies five years in yeah but sometimes they are actually Founders and they own a huge chunk and they actually get the company started there it's like it's such a strange concept yeah it's different for for everybody it has to make sense for the team it did it did right so because when guillam and Christina came into the business game came with like 10 years of experience living in China Hardware experience the connections on the ground we built a proprietary scooter from from scratch so what we had on the streets were not unique was unique it was not mass produced off the shelf like uh all the other brands were doing at the time was that a good idea in hindsight indeed because we were able to do it very very cost efficiently so we didn't raise a lot of capital but building your own Hardware is it cost efficient really so again when we say building in in our context it was having the right connections to a Syndicate of suppliers that have the capability to put something together relatively fast so you design it designed it and the parts are built you don't create your own battery and your own wheel obviously yeah but you need your own stock you need to make some some kind of upfront investment it's different that you have a service no I think plenty of competitors were working with xiaomi back then I think yeah indeed but when you compared what we put to Market yeah it was an advantage it was an advantage it didn't break all the time I remember as a user it was like a tank right if you recall it was uh and we still have I mean still a lot of them in in various uh inventory Depots around which which will be liquidated at some point but yeah so that was um so it was an advantage and we saw it uh early in the journey uh and we were able to do it pretty Capital efficiently without raising Millions like other players you might say you race so the initial initial something like when I when I was Operation involved we raised about in the first round about three and a half million and then another five so eight eight and a half million in equity and then really invest somebody from Tesla or something did I imagine the story so it wasn't exactly so it was one of the original board members of Tesla every house uh this investor called Simon Rothman who uh card is our first check actually [Music] yeah so you get three and a half then five four million you have the China person that knows the producers builds your own scooter you build an app yeah you view demand yeah we built our own uh firmware how does it started working everything what are the Milestones of Robbie yeah what do you think what do you do the first 12 months for example yeah yeah how far do you go um so we started I think in July of 2018.
- um by I think October November we had built the basic platform right so the app no app was just the icing on the cake so I'm talking about the iot okay wow so yeah the BMS the battery management system everything was was ready and this was like from scratch to from nothing to something right the first proprietary sorry the first prototypes we were testing in November and by first to second week of December we were able to put out 50 scooters in Barcelona and this was uh this was interesting because uh we obviously didn't there was a regular I mean there was a regulatory gray area uh we were able to explore it turns out it wasn't great eventually yeah yeah so uh but there were some workarounds we came out with the lock anchoring the scooter to bike bike racks and so on which actually helped keep theft damage and the littering problem address those things we were in a litigious process here in our Flagship Market which was unfortunate but you know we kept going to the city with the city uh did you meet with kolau uh not directly but uh with the rest of her team and this was uh quite a challenge because we moved ahead without let's say their blessing uh but as far as why did they you know why did they hate so much this kind of things well they still do right they still do yeah well look so I was rather so we were all very idealized right in in pursuing something like this okay we're gonna disrupt public Mobility uh we're gonna disrupt in a good way in a good way it can also mean yeah yeah but but in hindsight I don't so there are other markets like Saragosa where there is a real uh mobility issue public transportation is sparse if you go there at certain times of the day you can't find a cab there's there's this Motors and whatnot but there's nothing else in between at that time it was the case so there it made a lot of sense but in a city like Barcelona where you have um you know millions of tourists it is a public nuisance I give you that it is a public nuisance right so free floating uh it can create problems it it is yeah it does create problems and I'll be you know you have to be honest and acknowledge that so and especially around you know dense neighborhoods like the gothic and so on yeah it's not nice right so people zipping around these things um yeah things it hadn't been proven out uh there were there was a lot to be desired was there some specific incident uh no do you remember like somebody I don't know falling dying somebody's dying on a no not on so fortunately you know but there was one incident where someone was hurt uh but nothing no no fatalities as I recall as far as I was I was I was involved but what did the the city hall uh argument what was it so the argument was um this is not approved no one uh it's it needs there needs to be a proper process uh it needs to be evaluated in terms of safety in terms of all of that we went through the process of registering each one of these vehicles with the city hall there was a process that we that we that we fulfilled a new process because it was a new process a new process but we registered them just like all the other Mobility operators like the bicycles yeah so we had the motorbikes exactly we had the QR code and everything uh so we we fulfilled all those requirements but you know it's a political thing right so you can't influence it uh you you do your best you work around using the experience that we built here in Barcelona and and the and the uh the density and the number of rides um we were able to drive operational excellence in terms of building a capability of maintaining the fleet building Partnerships with you know 3pl's third-party Logistics providers uh building that capability and exporting it to other markets such as all of these other places that maybe eventually ended up operating in through public tenders so taking this experience building working closely with building a legal strategy having a very strong legal team that was enabling all of these other cities to you know come up with a public policy around Transportation participating in those rfps and building long-term relationships with those cities so it it to that end it really helped but it was it's a shame that we couldn't operate in your home City in the home City exactly but you know I mean it is a challenge I remember I was a heavy user of Ruby for a while because they were the fastest anything most available ways of transportation around me but I remember going to Paris with you actually uh in 2018 do you remember I was shocked like the the the the Seas of scooters Fallen everywhere in the middle of the of the sidewalks and same in London there was nothing compared to China and the bicycles but it wasn't a pleasant experience like you're in the center of Paris and my feeling is like what's all this crap here in the middle yeah right like that's that's that was my and I want tools like this but it is a challenge to the city no but there needs to be a way to solve it but a great point because what happened in Paris specifically citing this example they did a referendum right uh six months ago and and the citizens voted against removing so they want they want the scooters no they voted against suitors ah okay so they don't want anything yeah so they didn't referendum About Scooters yeah wow yeah [Music] it's great for haters but it says we can open the box of democracy now but the consequence is that you know Paris is not going to have scooters they know this sort of uh free-floating uh Mobility options is going to be gone bicycles bicycles will continue it's kind of weird no why they're not that different they have two wheels and the problem is the sidewalk no if they are feeling the sidewalk yeah no yeah the scooters right but in a dense City like Barcelona and Paris and so on where you just don't have the public infrastructure it's very hard yeah but for example Barcelona got the the circulation right like I think we are one of the fastest growing cities in Europe in number of uh bicycle Lanes I don't know how you call them yeah so that part I think we kind of got right the problem is where do you leave the stuff like you're not going to take it home when people live in tiny Apartments so it's a good idea to rent it and share it but then where do we put them very popular in Barcelona but for some reason scooters are very hated yeah but not only the Public Services also the private scooters are kind of forbidden or anything no no you have to go in particular places you have to wear yeah speaking you're not supposed to ride on um on the aceras so on the side yeah but but yeah practically speaking you see people zipping by you so there's a nuisance Factor right so I'm not surprised that there's been a huge backlash and so coming back to to rebi uh scooters were just one mode of Transport so we had bicycles for you foreign the plan obviously was to include other modes of Transport like Motors scooters did you get there uh eventually yes yeah okay yeah so since they disappeared from Barcelona I never knew yeah so I um did it so it was basically um a different kind of model a franchise model okay you know um franchisees use the platform to to basically offer their offerings so yes and and if there was not no regulation problem would it be a good business because somehow I don't know the the all these players that appeared they went dying one by one and yeah so you know there has to be some some problem so there's space so there's very few uh operators left from that original cohort of American companies right so like the limes and limes still is still one of the dominant players but practically gone uh and then in Europe you have uh the Swedish Warrior which is still got a dominant presence in the nodding Sierra tier and boy I think are emerged or something to actually in fact yeah so yeah they're they're still relevant uh and the vast majority of other players have disappeared right or practically disappearing so it's a tough model uh uh it's we had the right instincts to invest in in and build a capability ground up from the hardware and so on um so to that end while it lasted it was it was good um but it's it's the unit economics are very strong a very hard way because the cost to serve is is very is very high the logistics is not cheap so the cost is what uh 1000 Euros a scooter no no um so um yes but we were able to do it for significantly less less than a thousand yeah 500 more or less 500 scooter then there's a maintenance so the maintenance is very is is problematic so maintenance being recharging so if you have a replaceable replaceable batteries it drops significantly but that adds on a lot of cost and you need people actual humans who will change the battery around the city also operationally is expensive uh you need to move the actual scooters to the point because there's typically a start point and end point and they're not the same yeah yeah but that also depends on the usage no so the usage has a percentage of cost for repairing and recharging and redistribution right so ultimately it comes down to uh so we have to be able to redistribute the fleet uh to certain points in where there's demand is going to be right so if you take uh what happened let's say in the peak months between July to September eighty percent of the fleet would be in uh in the Benoit area so you need to move those things back to uh what does these people do they just stay in the beach uh or I suppose yeah so it's just congregation they just get drunk and stay there so it can be frustrating in that sense from a user perspective if you don't distribute uh so we we did a decent job but that was not cost efficient we didn't crack that model there were algorithms that incentivated that people would take yeah from one place to another yeah so we we did that uh but you know the start and stop was very frustrating right so we didn't have enough operational data to be able to really optimize those models to be able to drive real value because you know you one week you'd be on one week you'd be off uh this cat and mouse with a city which is frustrating it uh it didn't help uh so you mean start and stop in terms of Regulation yeah that the police would suddenly yeah stop people right I remember Cesar telling me like police is stopping people driving uh riding on a rebi or other as good there's suddenly one week it's like don't don't get on one or you might get in trouble and then next week he was okay and they would be fine if you were driving I never got one there were people who were fined yes really yeah there were people who find she's like as a Founder which is hard enough then again fighting against the police like on top of everything fighting against the market and fighting against the place it was challenging uh to say the least um anyway so ready was um a great experience in that so you you left after a couple three years something like that so yeah I uh two years in I left my operational role so I uh I exited I so it was also um the timing also had to do with when we went to the franchise model around the pandemics time frame uh I opted out and it was also a combination of factors right so Andreas the CEO and co-founder of two had come back from linear he was in Norway getting ready to start something up we had a couple of chats to build something that would become too was really interesting and just you know I'd like to touch upon this and it'll be a perfect segue to get into why two came about and what was the problem we were solving so in our experience at uh linear Lineo is a Marketplace uh Merchant right so we were selling stuff on behalf of merchants and about 20 of our clientele clients where business is making purchases on our platform and typically these businesses required to make or to make purchases on invoice right so with some deferred mode of payment some credit and as big as linear was it was not a core competency we could not credit on the right we could not have a verify identity issue invoices follow-up collections all of that it was a huge challenge and we were losing a lot of sales a typical experience of some of these customers would they would come into the you know checkout page and they'd they'd see pay with credit card pay with cash they pick up the phone call customer service how can I pay on invoice I want to buy 50 TVs uh you know pay in 30 days 60 days in 30 days we try to establish some of the sales would be loosen so that's the point the the the challenge that we are trying to solve or we are solving here today with two and you know that resonated really well with me early stage let's get this going working again with Andreas on on this was amazing so uh it was you know tough decision to make to leave rabi uh that was very understanding can you can you share with us um because this is something that happens in startups when founders start a company with all the dreams and illusion of what's going to happen and then at some point things go south or things don't go as expected and then they have this conversation yeah so how do you manage this conversation with your co-founders yeah so with a lot of uh guilt uh and uh and stress obviously um so it was a tough time for the business it was you know the pandemic was on uh the business was slowly getting back on its feet I had this thing uh this was precisely three years ago so September in 2020.
- um so yeah I I was clear in what I wanted and I was also uh at a point in my life uh where I wanted to put myself and my family forward right first the review experience was great and where I was within the company what I could offer in terms of regulatory uh aspects of things fundraising uh and so on I wasn't adding a lot of value there personally so it was a reckoning now look I could do better somewhere else or I could continue here and I think you know when I had that conversation with pep it was hard but he was understanding you know this is ultimately a where your heart is is what you do and I stayed on in a you know advisory capacity uh beyond that but I I I removed myself from a day-to-day um starting you know 2020 September October and then around January when things really started picking up with two I was fully out so fully out as in also selling you shares or you stayed a shareholder I stayed as a shareholder uh until um until the the acquisition uh by Seoul uh or House of lithium which was basically they let us use a at rebbe this was just after I I left so they were one of the biggest investors the Lead Series investor is the one that offered to acquire the company correct yeah that offered uh signed well yeah I mean that's something I wanted to ask about because for but but then in this series hey if there was a secondary and is where you left no I I didn't settle at the series a so I sold uh before before the acquisition just before the acquisition okay and then how did what happened with Robbie yeah exactly between the news here it was recently in the news yeah so it's um it's still in in litigation so in the US in the US uh because this is a Delaware Corporation and uh the last outcome was that you know it we need to basically go to trial again and yeah that's where it is so this house of lithium came to rabi and said I want to buy you or Robbie went to them and say we want to sell I'm not on on top of the details uh there but basically they were one of the investors right so lead investor with a with a significant stake in the business already prior to the acquisition and from what I understand their strategy was to build a constellation of Brands right so around probability uh battery management uh and so on and ready was fit into the the picture as one one piece of that puzzle uh and they had acquired another cost another company in the battery space uh and so on and this was basically the plan to float uh an entity that gets uh on the on the Canadian Stock Exchange So to that end the review deal would be you know review would be acquired wholly uh by house uh yeah like um you know cash to pay out the the equity holders uh and and some Surplus for for for some early for the management team or exactly and that was basically the team but it was a good a good outcome for the founders and for the investors if it had gone through from what I understand it would have been a fantastic uh outcome for uh the shareholders acquisition yeah because they and for the company that would survive yeah yeah but you know the way things ended up is that uh what happened what what's the Tipping Point so litigation is expensive but why is there litigation no what happened probably is that the market Fall so the world financial Market there's many things right so one is uh yes so the company needed a response right so either through an acquisition or through the private markets uh as a extension to the series A or B or whatever we have we had a term sheet that was executed and signed uh not term sheet a sale document everything done so the transaction the transaction was assigned typically in a transaction document like this you have like 30 days to wire the money and stuff like that a portion of the funds were wired as well a portion of the funds was wired yeah a small portion yeah so the deal was had happened in the second the second wire never came the The Joint statement the press release was will happen with them so there was a there was an article crunch everything yeah that's true so everything went out and then yeah it was like uh I suppose a Twitter Elon moment on their end um and they they've done their best to get out of it so they decided to walk back the acquisition yeah excited legally yeah and that's basically where we are today it's uh that sucks you have a Twitter I mean I don't lost yeah let's say no yeah so I don't know that I know don't know the document but depends on how it's written especially in the US well it looks quite effective explicitly said he doesn't want anything diligence like he signed the worst possible contract apparently yeah but it should be quite effective in the US maybe in Spain that could be two years but or more or more yeah so you know for practical purposes there is a There's Hope um yeah yeah I think you know that they're forced to pay and then but how can that we hope I mean the company cannot survive like people cannot stay waiting for money to arrive no that's true so things are uh where they are today because of that because of that reason yeah I'm sure there's an infinite detail right there the thing is you went then uh you met Andreas again uh with it was somebody you you liked when you worked with him and and you felt like that was a good opportunity for you um and and what and the beach was what you said before no solving this problem that you're covered in basically what is two we offer an API payment method for API based payment method for B2B so B2B specific you can simplify it by saying it's a buy now pay later solution for specifically for B2B so what that entails is we enable um businesses that make purchases so all people that make purchases on behalf of your business so let's take the use case of factorial purchasing computers from Apple or uh or Amazon right so you have an account a trade account with one of these companies that's a real case we do that yeah so uh and uh and two basically offers a fund fully funded invoice solution to Amazon to fund um the purchases on behalf of factory so we don't pay Apple you pay Apple correct and then we pay you correct and this is an API only so I didn't even know that you exist Apple provides this to us so it depends on the operating model and where we operate we are not a white label solution per se so we exist as a payment so the financing agreement is with you the the end exactly so we uh help the merchant delegate all of the collections uh the risk the the credit and the fraud risk to us so it's closer to Atlanta or an affirm yeah the difference is the buyer is specifically B2B exactly so it's a much larger what changes product space when the buyer is a B2B for from whose perspective from the business perspective yeah the risk is a lot harder to assess because you know you don't have uh credit bureau information so it's a capability to build that we we have now three years under our belt doing it in three markets do you have algorithms or data or something we've built when I put factorial ink which is not a real name that I put their company name then you know How likely you are to get the money back yeah exactly so we we built we've invested and make that happen um so we give you um a credit worthiness score and then you know right away whether you can continue with the purchase or not and in some cases the merchant has the capability to show whether the payment method is relevant for you or not they're factoring now so factoring so factoring happens in a post sale context where the issue or the invoice is created and then you sell the invoice so what we're doing is real-time decision making right so we're doing it at the point of sale so yes it is factoring but it's factoring with a Twist the invoice in the user experience though it's a much faster the risk ass salesman and everything it's the same thing is the seller no who decides to do that so I sell you something expensive you're going to pay me 90 days and I go to the bank and I say I want the money now and the bank gives it to me the seller no that's another thing that is factoring factoring is not a seller yeah that's how I understand factoring it's a seller who gets this so your account payables right so your account receivable you can sell your I want to get the money earlier exactly exactly well obviously at a cost for me so you partner with Apple no so that would be great uh we no so our uh so in Sweden we operate with uh net on net which is one of the largest uh e-commerce uh players in the region in Norway the authorized Apple distributor is uh office to as a payment method uh so we service everything from SAS consultancies physical Goods uh purchasing and uh and in the construction space as well so marketplaces are also an option are you judge who we charge the margin so no matter so it's it's it's exactly like offering uh later no so think of it like you have you're selling a product on your site right and you offer credit card as a payment method so you're basically we're we're basically the payment method instead of you paying stripe you're paying us and you have a parameter of better conversion exactly much higher conversion what are they paying for specifically for B2B right so so back to your case in linear so coming so when they wanted 40 TVs and they didn't want to pay up front they didn't buy if they lost their sales it's a lost lost sale opportunity that you that you that you don't lose um then the operational complexity right most businesses are not in the should not be in the business of credit underwriting Collections and so on right so it's operationally complex there's overhead that is outsourced to two so two basically does all of that on behalf of those customers so if the customer doesn't pay it's always your problem it's my it's our problem exactly so you're very motivated to do the correct underwriting exactly exactly not just for your customer but because otherwise you take this yeah we take the hit of course so this is a capability that uh what what is what's the price what's the interest rate so there's no interest so it's not interest rate based it's basically a transaction fee service yeah it's a transaction fee in interest so think of it I will convert it as an interest if I would be a seller so think of it as the it's on par with the transaction fee that you would pay strike or for an Amex transaction right so like a two each percent to each percent yeah okay on on a 15 to 30 day invoice so if if it's a different product which is basically installments which we could do anywhere between three to 12 months it will be higher and how do you collect the money how do they pay you um you cannot pay stripe no yeah exactly it's wire transfer why transfer or uh and then you have an army of collections agents that are calling um you know so we're pretty efficient so we're in the northern switch I guess yeah so we do have a small collections team which is like one or two people uh it's very small for a business that only does this basically yeah yeah and the UK as well um so it's basically UK should be maybe more challenging so our basically a Collections Unit is about three people but it's it's highly organized automated so our bank operations um yes uh there are it's a small it's a small percentage but you know in in this business what you do is you don't you build up you build up the confidence right so there are some first time there is there is first party fraud uh but it's a very small percentage we don't take big risks and there is an identity verification piece associated with with the buyer experience you don't take big marginal drift invoice by invoice but in some you're thinking another place yeah but it's Diversified right it's across Industries it's across multiple how much money is Lent out right now for example this is the number you track uh roughly is it like in the millions tens of millions so we're transacting in the almost double digits uh volume per month on a monthly basis so eight nine whatever seven eight nine million no slightly more than that okay we're on track to basically 2x uh 2.5 x what we did in 2022 okay the the demand is that growth is there and we're and you said Norway Sweden Norway Sweden and UK and the UK is a no-brainer I mean if you're giving money to the people that's always a man the question is how can you build a business a sustainable business sustainable business indeed so and do you go to SMB or you go to large Enterprise it's totally different risk so yes so we are we we had to start at the lower end which is small small and medium business the risk is there but you know if you build uh so think about it this way right so who's taking the risk today is the merchant if they don't offer any Services any any buy now pay later or let's say they are just extending invoice or net terms on invoice they're taking the risk the sales are growing and what they're doing is basically forwarding us good customers there's a need there's a digital good or bad customer good customer so the good customer they can do it themselves yeah but they're taking so nobody give good customer but there's a working capital issue right so if you if they're going to pay you in 30 days what we're doing is we pay you right away so there is a valuable position there okay there's no collections they don't have to have a team running after but why don't they give you the bad customers too if they get paid today sure of course we give us customers exactly so good about has to pay for the collection people the risk that you are taking and the whole business so it's a high volume business it's a high volume business it's like payments right payments is um it's a high scale business you have to you have to be operating you need to get to the billions yeah and that's for there to be a business yeah that's um that's the part we're on uh the trajectory of our own and uh so far so good so so and and you said you it raised the reason it raised money and yeah so we uh so we raised our initial round um in 2021 so a good time yeah so precede uh uh which was led by uh Sequoia and local Globe uh and Visionaries club and then we followed that up in the summer with a with a seed round and then a series a round uh we we closed it last October uh anymore yeah but you know it's uh the timing was uh could have been worse but we did we did well in that sense uh did you race in total so the most recent round was about 20 million uh USD so in total we're at about 28.
Descripción
Hoy hablamos con Kiran Thomas, fundador de Reby y Two. Kiran ha vivido en cuatro continentes y ha emprendido en cuatro sectores distintos.
Desde sus comienzos en la India, Kiran nos cuenta el increíble recorrido que le ha llevado a asentarse en Barcelona. Nos cuenta cómo pasó por e-commerce con Lineo, tratando de crear el Amazon de LATAM, por el sector del retail con Privalia, la movilidad con Reby y el fintech con Two, su último proyecto que se describe como un buy now, pay later para B2B.
En esta conversación, Kiran indaga especialmente en el polémico caso de Reby en su actual proyecto, con sede en Oslo, que tiene como objetivo convertirse en una de las grandes fintechs B2B.
PATROCINADORES
Factorial: https://rebrand.ly/factorial_hr
EVENTOS
Jueves de Itnig (18h30) - https://itnig.net/events/
Itnig Talks - https://rebrand.ly/playlist_itnig_talks
SOBRE ITNIG
Twitter - https://twitter.com/itnig
LinkedIn - https://es.linkedin.com/company/itnig
Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/itnig/
Newsletter - https://itnig.net/newsletter/
Web - https://itnig.net/
ESCUCHA NUESTRO PODCAST EN
Spotify: http://bit.ly/itnigspotify
Apple Podcast: http://bit.ly/itnigapple
TENGO UN PROYECTO
Si tienes un proyecto tecnológico y buscas financiación, completa este formulario y presenta tu proyecto en nuestro Pitch to Investors. https://itnig.net/fund
00:00:00 En este episodio
00:02:30 De la India a Barcelona
00:08:10 Formación como programador y trabajar en EEUU
00:10:10 La historia de Lineo
00:13:30 Pep Gómez, Reby y Ada Colau
00:31:30 Pasar de Reby a Two
00:39:45 Two, el factoring y el futuro
00:53:40 Influencias
Captions con timestamps
Mostrar captions con tiempo Ocultar captions con tiempo
[00:00] did you meet with kolau not directly but [00:02] [00:02] with the rest of her team and this was [00:04] [00:04] quite a challenge because we moved ahead [00:06] [00:06] without let's say their blessing there [00:08] [00:08] were people who were fined yet really [00:10] [00:10] yeah there are people who find she's [00:12] [00:12] like as a Founder which is hard enough [00:14] [00:14] then again [00:16] [00:16] fighting against the police like on top [00:17] [00:17] of everything fighting against the [00:19] [00:19] market and fighting against the place it [00:21] [00:21] was challenging uh to say the least and [00:23] [00:23] then how did what happened with Robbie [00:25] [00:25] yeah exactly between the news it was [00:28] [00:28] recently in the news yeah so it's um [00:30] [00:30] it's still in in litigation so in the US [00:33] [00:33] in the US is [01:03] [01:03] [Music] [01:15] [01:15] engagement [01:25] [01:25] [Music] [01:36] [01:36] [Music] [02:00] [02:00] bienvenido [02:12] [02:12] [Music] [02:25] [02:25] daily [02:29] [02:29] welcome everybody I'm Bernard Ferrero [02:31] [02:31] today I'm with Jordan Romero how are you [02:33] [02:33] Jersey very good I'm with Kiran Thomas [02:34] [02:34] how are you kidding doing well thanks [02:36] [02:36] Kiran is a consultant initially then [02:39] [02:39] executive then entrepreneur [02:43] [02:43] yeah there was a period in between where [02:44] [02:45] it was also part of the founding team of [02:46] [02:46] uh which is today latam's let's say top [02:48] [02:48] five uh [02:50] [02:50] a general merchandise retailers in the [02:52] [02:52] world in the region called Lineo so I [02:54] [02:54] was one I was part of the founding team [02:55] [02:55] there as well so okay part of the [02:58] [02:58] journey okay so in in entrepreneurship [03:02] [03:02] you've participated in projects around [03:03] [03:03] Mobility with Rabbi yeah [03:06] [03:06] fintech with two and e-commerce with [03:09] [03:09] linear and e-commerce and you are from [03:12] [03:12] India originally that's correct so yeah [03:14] [03:14] my roots are there I was born and raised [03:15] [03:15] there uh so my formative years were [03:19] [03:19] living were there and then I after my [03:22] [03:22] education which is engineering degree in [03:24] [03:24] computer science [03:25] [03:25] I immigrated to the United States where [03:28] [03:28] I [03:28] [03:28] started working and got acquainted with [03:31] [03:31] what in the US [03:32] [03:32] so most of my uh life in the US was [03:35] [03:35] based in Chicago and the Chicago land [03:37] [03:37] area a little bit also in in the St [03:39] [03:39] Louis Minneapolis area for [03:41] [03:41] consulting-based project work somehow [03:44] [03:44] life brought you to Barcelona yeah life [03:47] [03:47] wrong you live here you're happily [03:48] [03:48] living for a while yeah yes near from [03:51] [03:51] where we're recording this very close by [03:52] [03:52] uh setting down Roots uh literally [03:55] [03:55] speaking so my uh uh two I have two kids [03:58] [03:58] they both go to school here they're [03:59] [04:00] growing up here trilingual obviously [04:01] [04:01] they've trilingual so Catalan in school [04:04] [04:04] uh Spanish at home with my wife and [04:06] [04:06] English with me okay yeah okay we'll [04:09] [04:09] talk about Ravi and and two which I [04:11] [04:11] think they're very interesting cases but [04:12] [04:12] maybe we can follow the chronological [04:14] [04:14] order from your Beginnings now as a [04:17] [04:17] studying computer science in India maybe [04:19] [04:19] you can share with us how how is [04:21] [04:21] environment in India to start computer [04:23] [04:23] science it's very well known for having [04:26] [04:26] great talent in computer science and [04:28] [04:28] great universities [04:29] [04:29] indeed yeah and and why did you emigrate [04:32] [04:32] why did you go out from India sure so [04:36] [04:36] um when I was in university uh in the in [04:39] [04:39] the late uh 90s early 2000s it was a [04:42] [04:42] boom time when you know the I.T [04:44] [04:44] Consulting uh phase of of uh of the [04:48] [04:48] industry so India was at the time uh [04:50] [04:50] servicing most of the West in terms of [04:52] [04:52] BPO so business process Outsourcing and [04:55] [04:55] so on a lot of Consulting work was [04:56] [04:56] coming and being done in the country [04:57] [04:57] India was going through a point a time [04:59] [04:59] when we were solving problems for the [05:01] [05:01] rest of the world rather than internal [05:03] [05:03] problems but that's not techno you talk [05:05] [05:05] about things more like accounting yeah [05:07] [05:07] business classes Insurance yeah call [05:10] [05:10] centers and also [05:12] [05:12] um development work right so okay a lot [05:14] [05:15] of enterprise software uh work was being [05:17] [05:17] done income on behalf of large [05:19] [05:19] Consulting companies the IBM's Accenture [05:23] [05:23] Deloitte so on and so forth so it was [05:25] [05:25] quite common to be you know campus [05:27] [05:27] recruited by national firms so [05:29] [05:29] deloittees Etc start in India and then [05:31] [05:31] Branch over get yourself a H1 Visa and [05:34] [05:34] go to the America and go to the US that [05:36] [05:36] was a difficult path so I had that [05:38] [05:38] option that's what I did it was the done [05:40] [05:40] thing one you know it just catapulted [05:44] [05:44] your career in many ways uh by being [05:45] [05:45] able to go there and being sort of let's [05:47] [05:47] say trained in a way to go and take on [05:50] [05:50] challenges in that market right so was [05:52] [05:52] it like your plan from early on like I'm [05:55] [05:55] gonna do these four steps so I can go to [05:57] [05:57] the US or it just kind of happened they [05:59] [05:59] tell you this is It's opportunity it's a [06:01] [06:01] bit of both so I had the opportunity and [06:04] [06:04] also had you know family there so it [06:06] [06:06] made the reason for me to go there a lot [06:08] [06:08] more on your ring so yeah so it was a [06:10] [06:10] mix of consequences right it was not and [06:12] [06:12] it was a time when it was the done thing [06:14] [06:14] not to say that doesn't happen now but [06:17] [06:17] now there's more of a homegrown industry [06:19] [06:19] than that you know is solving big [06:22] [06:22] problems in India this and people are [06:24] [06:24] finding that a lot more exciting and [06:26] [06:26] people stay in the country so it used to [06:27] [06:27] be more like the company and the capital [06:29] [06:29] is in the US or some other countries and [06:32] [06:32] then they hire labor talent in India [06:34] [06:34] yeah yeah and what you're saying is now [06:36] [06:36] there is more businesses in India hiding [06:38] [06:38] their talent locally and just selling [06:40] [06:40] their services abroad yeah so now [06:42] [06:42] there's a concept of building built in [06:44] [06:44] India built for the problems in India [06:45] [06:45] and Export those Solutions worldwide [06:47] [06:47] right which which makes sense in the [06:49] [06:49] past it was solving problems in the west [06:51] [06:51] exporting those solutions to third world [06:53] [06:53] countries and and developing countries [06:55] [06:55] and now there's a reckoning that you [06:58] [06:58] know there are real problems to be [06:59] [06:59] solved here there's capital in those [07:00] [07:00] markets of course some Capital comes [07:03] [07:03] from from from outside the country and [07:05] [07:05] this is much stronger value proposition [07:07] [07:07] really I think more than exporting the [07:09] [07:09] products is building the internal Market [07:11] [07:11] I mean it's a huge Market we're in Spain [07:14] [07:14] where 40 something million people and [07:17] [07:17] and many many companies are based on [07:19] [07:19] focus in the Spanish Market which [07:20] [07:20] doesn't make much sense but when you are [07:21] [07:21] 1.3 billion people then it makes sense [07:24] [07:24] and growing and growing with lots of [07:27] [07:27] opportunity to much of the West yeah and [07:29] [07:29] and presently with the current [07:30] [07:30] Administration uh that is so [07:32] [07:32] pro-business uh women of India I mean [07:35] [07:35] the current government in India is pro [07:36] [07:36] so pro-business uh has put a lot of [07:39] [07:39] foundational elements in growing the [07:41] [07:41] economy right from identity verification [07:43] [07:43] to imagine the scale of the challenge [07:46] [07:46] right when you're talking about 1.4 1.5 [07:49] [07:49] billion people being able to offer them [07:51] [07:51] uh you know fintech services like real [07:54] [07:54] uh you know there was an unbanked [07:56] [07:56] population of what you know 60 70 now [07:58] [07:58] that's being reduced uh so there's real [08:01] [08:01] value generation in that in in society [08:03] [08:03] in India that that's on you know that's [08:05] [08:05] coming at an unprecedented rate right so [08:07] [08:07] nothing has happened like that in the [08:08] [08:08] past so yeah so I studied Computing uh [08:12] [08:12] but always had let's say a flare or an [08:15] [08:15] interest in pursuing something on the [08:17] [08:17] edge between the intersection between [08:19] [08:19] business and and and the tax and Tech [08:21] [08:21] area so my career in that sense sort of [08:24] [08:24] weird off into the analytics area so [08:26] [08:27] that's what I first cut my feet doing in [08:29] [08:29] in the retail sector [08:30] [08:30] working for a large big box retailer [08:32] [08:32] called Office Max [08:34] [08:34] um in the Chicago Chicago land area so [08:36] [08:36] it was instrumental in their post merger [08:38] [08:38] integration structure yeah Wilson you [08:41] [08:41] know experience especially at scale so [08:43] [08:43] we're talking about uh at the time [08:45] [08:45] the operations were somewhere in the [08:47] [08:47] range of about 2000 stores across the [08:49] [08:49] country offline retail and its [08:51] [08:51] challenges when it comes to [08:52] [08:52] replenishment forecasting purchasing and [08:54] [08:54] all of that that led me into uh an [08:58] [08:58] opportunity in the career in the retail [08:59] [08:59] sector uh in Consulting and Accenture [09:01] [09:01] accenture's retail practice I did that [09:03] [09:03] for quite a few years and got there was [09:06] [09:06] management consulting or Tech Consulting [09:08] [09:08] a bit of both again so I was uh so I was [09:11] [09:11] I had a very unorthodox experience there [09:14] [09:14] as well so I was responsible for the [09:16] [09:16] client management of a very large uh [09:19] [09:19] retailer called Best Buy and the [09:21] [09:21] international expansion it was fantastic [09:23] [09:23] it was I was living in Mexico I was [09:25] [09:25] living in the UK so they were sending [09:28] [09:28] you to different places for this [09:29] [09:29] Consulting agreement so it was the same [09:30] [09:30] account but I was responsible for a [09:33] [09:33] significant piece of uh of the [09:35] [09:35] implementation and so on so I spent a [09:37] [09:37] better part of three years living out of [09:39] [09:39] my suitcase at that point in my life it [09:41] [09:41] was great [09:42] [09:42] I can't imagine doing that now and [09:45] [09:45] decided that you know [09:46] [09:46] the next stage of my life would be [09:49] [09:49] something in entrepreneurship building [09:50] [09:50] on on the experience I had 11 I mean God [09:54] [09:54] until that point and then was very [09:57] [09:57] fortunate to be make an entry into the [09:59] [09:59] e-commerce uh entrepreneurship side of [10:01] [10:01] things setting up uh lineal [10:03] [10:03] lineupont.com headquartered in Mexico [10:05] [10:05] which and expanding it into seven [10:08] [10:08] countries across Lata how did linear get [10:10] [10:10] started like who comes up with the idea [10:11] [10:12] recruits the founding team yeah how is [10:13] [10:13] the structure so because it's a bit of [10:15] [10:15] an unusual case yeah indeed so it's it's [10:17] [10:17] not entrepreneurship as you would as we [10:20] [10:20] would do it today where you're starting [10:21] [10:21] everything from scratch I mean it's [10:23] [10:23] something you can do starting of a boy [10:25] [10:25] band right it's kind of you bring [10:27] [10:27] together uh key players and you put them [10:29] [10:29] together give them Capital exposure and [10:31] [10:31] so on and so someone at Rocket said [10:33] [10:33] there is an opportunity in e-commerce in [10:35] [10:35] latam yeah Samus pitch was [10:37] [10:37] do you want to be [10:39] [10:39] um I recall this do you want to be uh [10:43] [10:43] sleeping under your desk as a banking [10:47] [10:47] executive in in in in in Investment [10:50] [10:50] Banking or working on the spam filter [10:52] [10:52] for for [10:54] [10:54] for Google or do you want to be creating [10:57] [10:57] the next Amazon in uh in Latin America [10:59] [10:59] right so interestingly enough that copy [11:02] [11:02] that from Steve Jobs no do you want to [11:03] [11:03] keep selling sugar water possibly the [11:05] [11:05] guy from Pepsi some iteration okay but [11:08] [11:08] nevertheless it's strong it works it [11:10] [11:10] struck a very uh strong chord with me so [11:12] [11:12] I joined uh Lineo like two two or three [11:16] [11:16] months in so I wasn't I didn't get the [11:18] [11:18] designation of co-founder so for three [11:21] [11:21] months I mean three months it's not so [11:23] [11:23] it's not very much but then you know you [11:24] [11:24] had you so I met uh so Andreas who is my [11:28] [11:28] co-founder at two [11:30] [11:30] um he was he was the founder and CEO at [11:33] [11:33] um at linear we had a call I was in [11:35] [11:35] Mexico he said come join me so I was one [11:37] [11:37] of the first let's say executive not [11:38] [11:38] executive but one of the leadership team [11:40] [11:40] members uh my rolly bald so this was my [11:43] [11:43] first experience in e-commerce building [11:45] [11:45] out things from scratch to I was what [11:47] [11:47] employee number 30 or 40 within the team [11:50] [11:50] uh rapidly growing at its peak we were [11:53] [11:53] about 1600 people expanding across the [11:56] [11:56] region very crazy yeah this is very hard [11:59] [11:59] to manage well it's internet model yeah [12:01] [12:01] the vertical growth sometimes vertical [12:04] [12:04] crash yeah usually many times right so [12:07] [12:07] yeah so we we experienced the ups and [12:10] [12:10] downs uh it was a great learning [12:11] [12:11] experience great incubated model in that [12:13] [12:13] you you you build a lot of skills you [12:15] [12:15] learn things really fast so yeah just [12:17] [12:17] fond memories great experience how far [12:20] [12:20] did it go like like before you left how [12:22] [12:22] big was linear so linear when I left we [12:24] [12:24] were operating in six or seven countries [12:27] [12:27] Spanish speaking excellent Marketplace [12:30] [12:30] or e-commerce so we pivoted into a [12:32] [12:32] Marketplace so initially in the first [12:33] [12:33] year it was you know procured by uh [12:35] [12:36] model uh in I think year two or one [12:40] [12:40] around then we pivoted into a [12:42] [12:42] Marketplace model yeah what happened [12:43] [12:43] with the company it's a exited so it's [12:45] [12:45] sold yeah it's old so Falabella which is [12:48] [12:48] a Chilean retailer uh but made an [12:51] [12:51] acquisition in 2018. if you sort of [12:53] [12:53] compared with capital raised and uh [12:56] [12:56] relative to let's say valuation [12:58] [12:58] valuation yeah it was it was an okay [13:00] [13:00] exit for the management team not so [13:02] [13:02] great but for growth investors who came [13:04] [13:04] in late with liquidation preferences it [13:07] [13:07] was good it was a huge lesson yeah that [13:09] [13:09] unfortunately had the same in the past [13:12] [13:12] right and that's that's that's and you [13:14] [13:14] were based where when this was happening [13:16] [13:16] I was based in Mexico City and I moved [13:18] [13:18] to Barcelona in 2016. [13:21] [13:21] um so after this experience after the [13:23] [13:23] leading experience moved to Barcelona [13:25] [13:25] correct yeah but before the acquisition [13:26] [13:26] so yeah I was there for four years and [13:29] [13:29] then I left [13:30] [13:30] um yeah missed the acquisition by like [13:32] [13:32] uh 18 months I think it was pretty it [13:34] [13:34] was pretty intense from what I hear so [13:36] [13:36] at that moment you you met pep Gomez [13:39] [13:39] yeah so I know that for for my entry [13:41] [13:41] into into Barcelona so I'd known him uh [13:43] [13:43] from some of the events in the in the [13:45] [13:45] startup space what events maybe people [13:48] [13:48] everybody's looking for a co-founder so [13:50] [13:50] where did you meet your co-founder uh so [13:52] [13:52] he was part of Numa I think it was yeah [13:54] [13:54] uh so they their own events their own [13:56] [13:57] events it was an incubator or what was [13:58] [13:58] yeah so it's part of uh she had to come [14:01] [14:01] to the podcast and tell us what Numa was [14:03] [14:03] yeah you should have him on of course uh [14:05] [14:05] so Numa was [14:06] [14:06] um I I believe I don't know if they're [14:09] [14:09] still around but that was it was a an [14:11] [14:11] offshoot of Mobile World Congress right [14:13] [14:13] so it was part of the mobile World fund [14:16] [14:16] they had some participation in that uh [14:18] [14:18] and it was an incubator uh so Madam at [14:21] [14:21] one of the events there had some other [14:22] [14:22] connections but the type of event where [14:25] [14:25] there's just drinks and some couple of [14:27] [14:27] talks or something and you just went [14:28] [14:28] there too no actually I had a [14:30] [14:30] interesting enough that it reminds me I [14:33] [14:33] had another connection to pep just [14:35] [14:35] through his [14:36] [14:36] um girlfriend at the time he's a friend [14:38] [14:38] of uh my wife's sister so it was a [14:41] [14:42] random personal connection random [14:43] [14:43] personal connection coupled with events [14:45] [14:45] and so on getting done [14:48] [14:48] uh say it was you know a consequence of [14:51] [14:51] the time uh pep broke the the idea [14:55] [14:55] creation and so on so he was like pretty [14:58] [14:58] clear he wanted to do this uh we met [15:02] [15:02] around the time when I was uh leaving [15:04] [15:04] prevalia [15:05] [15:05] and we were living and then you met this [15:08] [15:08] or you met this opportunity and then you [15:10] [15:10] left prevalia was it no it was the other [15:12] [15:12] way around so I I left pre-value okay [15:14] [15:14] and I I started at uh with review so you [15:18] [15:18] wanted to start a company or yeah yeah [15:20] [15:20] so I wanted to start something the [15:21] [15:21] timing was just brilliant like uh [15:24] [15:24] uh when I was having my going away party [15:26] [15:26] at prevalia I was already Robbie was [15:28] [15:28] running so yeah so I remember discussing [15:31] [15:31] the welcome party next day no there was [15:33] [15:33] a welcome party it was just me [15:37] [15:38] and exactly buy Scooters or whatever you [15:40] [15:40] do the first day of the company and a [15:41] [15:42] week later we were in so it was two two [15:43] [15:43] Founders yeah initially uh and then we [15:46] [15:46] brought on about six months later two [15:48] [15:48] more [15:49] [15:49] um again and Christina who basically [15:52] [15:52] joined us [15:53] [15:53] um to build out the [15:55] [15:55] engineering let's say in the China angle [15:57] [15:57] of Engineering in China so chief [15:59] [15:59] engineer and chief China Hardware [16:01] [16:01] it's a hardware yeah Chef hardware and [16:04] [16:04] your Chief product or head of problem [16:06] [16:06] yeah this product everything else [16:09] [16:09] yeah uh I was actually the CEO initially [16:11] [16:11] I really so when I started when we [16:13] [16:13] started pep was everything to do with [16:15] [16:15] regulatory uh legal and fundraising [16:20] [16:20] um I thought you were gonna say he [16:21] [16:21] didn't do that because it doesn't sound [16:23] [16:23] so much fun he did the regulatory legal [16:25] [16:25] and fundraising that was bad and I was [16:28] [16:28] running all things uh from a serious [16:31] [16:31] standpoint okay very soon I realized [16:34] [16:34] that this was a hairy animal I wasn't [16:36] [16:36] excelling at a job so we game took over [16:39] [16:39] from me so Gamers uh who came in as a [16:42] [16:42] CEO uh also founder you know you could [16:46] [16:46] call him the founder yes so did you call [16:48] [16:48] him a Founder yeah yeah okay yeah and [16:50] [16:50] what the founder is it Equity certain [16:52] [16:52] Equity a significant stake in the [16:55] [16:55] business for uh for all uh founders of [16:59] [16:59] course yeah we've seen Founders join [17:01] [17:01] Founders joint companies five years in [17:02] [17:02] yeah but sometimes they are actually [17:04] [17:04] Founders and they own a huge chunk and [17:06] [17:06] they actually get the company started [17:07] [17:07] there it's like it's such a strange [17:09] [17:09] concept yeah it's different for for [17:11] [17:11] everybody it has to make sense for the [17:12] [17:12] team it did it did right so because when [17:16] [17:16] guillam and Christina came into the [17:17] [17:17] business game came with like 10 years of [17:19] [17:19] experience living in China Hardware [17:22] [17:22] experience the connections on the ground [17:24] [17:24] we built a proprietary scooter from from [17:28] [17:28] scratch so what we had on the streets [17:30] [17:30] were not unique was unique it was not [17:32] [17:32] mass produced off the shelf like uh all [17:36] [17:36] the other brands were doing at the time [17:37] [17:37] was that a good idea in hindsight indeed [17:40] [17:40] because we were able to do it very very [17:42] [17:42] cost efficiently so we didn't raise a [17:45] [17:45] lot of capital but building your own [17:46] [17:46] Hardware is it cost efficient really [17:49] [17:49] so again [17:51] [17:51] when we say building in in our context [17:54] [17:54] it was having the right connections to a [17:56] [17:56] Syndicate of suppliers that have the [17:59] [17:59] capability to put something together [18:00] [18:00] relatively fast [18:02] [18:02] so you design it designed it and the [18:05] [18:05] parts are built you don't create your [18:07] [18:07] own battery and your own wheel obviously [18:09] [18:09] yeah but you need your own stock you [18:10] [18:10] need to make some some kind of upfront [18:12] [18:12] investment it's different that you have [18:14] [18:14] a service [18:18] [18:18] no I think plenty of competitors were [18:20] [18:20] working with xiaomi back then I think [18:21] [18:21] yeah indeed but when you compared what [18:24] [18:24] we put to Market [18:25] [18:25] yeah it was an advantage it was an [18:27] [18:27] advantage it didn't break all the time I [18:30] [18:30] remember as a user it was like a tank [18:32] [18:32] right if you recall it was uh and we [18:35] [18:35] still have I mean still a lot of them in [18:37] [18:37] in various uh inventory Depots around [18:39] [18:39] which which will be liquidated at some [18:41] [18:41] point but yeah so that was um so it was [18:44] [18:44] an advantage and we saw it uh early in [18:47] [18:47] the journey uh and we were able to do it [18:49] [18:49] pretty Capital efficiently without [18:51] [18:51] raising Millions like other players you [18:53] [18:53] might say you race so the initial [18:55] [18:55] initial something like when I when I was [18:58] [18:58] Operation involved we raised about in [19:01] [19:01] the first round [19:02] [19:02] about three and a half million and then [19:04] [19:04] another five so eight eight and a half [19:06] [19:06] million in equity and then really [19:09] [19:09] invest somebody from Tesla or something [19:11] [19:11] did I imagine the story [19:13] [19:13] so it wasn't exactly so it was one of [19:15] [19:15] the original board members of Tesla [19:17] [19:18] every house uh this investor called [19:20] [19:20] Simon Rothman who uh card is our first [19:24] [19:24] check actually [19:27] [19:27] [Music] [19:28] [19:28] yeah so you get three and a half then [19:31] [19:31] five four million you have the China [19:33] [19:33] person that knows the producers builds [19:35] [19:35] your own scooter you build an app yeah [19:38] [19:38] you view demand yeah we built our own uh [19:41] [19:41] firmware how does it started working [19:42] [19:42] everything what are the Milestones of [19:45] [19:45] Robbie yeah what do you think what do [19:46] [19:46] you do the first 12 months for example [19:48] [19:48] yeah yeah how far do you go [19:50] [19:50] um so we started I think in July of [19:53] [19:53] 2018. [19:55] [19:55] um by [19:57] [19:57] I think October November we had built [20:00] [20:00] the basic platform right so the app no [20:03] [20:03] app was just the icing on the cake so [20:05] [20:05] I'm talking about the iot okay wow so [20:08] [20:08] yeah [20:10] [20:10] the BMS the battery management system [20:13] [20:13] everything was was ready and this was [20:15] [20:15] like from scratch to from nothing to [20:18] [20:18] something right the first proprietary [20:20] [20:20] sorry the first prototypes we were [20:22] [20:22] testing in November and by first to [20:24] [20:24] second week of December [20:26] [20:26] we were able to put out 50 scooters in [20:30] [20:30] Barcelona [20:31] [20:31] and this was uh this was interesting [20:33] [20:33] because uh [20:35] [20:35] we obviously didn't there was a regular [20:37] [20:37] I mean there was a regulatory gray area [20:40] [20:40] uh we were able to explore it turns out [20:41] [20:42] it wasn't great [20:43] [20:43] eventually yeah yeah so uh but there [20:46] [20:46] were some workarounds we came out with [20:48] [20:48] the lock anchoring the scooter to bike [20:51] [20:51] bike racks and so on which actually [20:53] [20:53] helped keep theft damage and the [20:56] [20:56] littering problem address those things [20:57] [20:57] we were in a litigious process here in [21:00] [21:00] our Flagship Market which was [21:01] [21:01] unfortunate but you know we kept going [21:03] [21:03] to the city with the city uh did you [21:05] [21:05] meet with kolau uh not directly but uh [21:09] [21:09] with the rest of her team and this was [21:10] [21:10] uh quite a challenge because we moved [21:12] [21:12] ahead without let's say their blessing [21:14] [21:14] uh but as far as why did they you know [21:18] [21:18] why did they hate so much this kind of [21:20] [21:20] things [21:21] [21:21] well they still do right they still do [21:22] [21:22] yeah well look so I was rather so we [21:26] [21:26] were all very idealized right in in [21:28] [21:28] pursuing something like this okay we're [21:30] [21:30] gonna disrupt public Mobility uh we're [21:33] [21:33] gonna disrupt in a good way in a good [21:35] [21:35] way it can also mean yeah yeah but but [21:36] [21:36] in hindsight I don't so there are other [21:39] [21:39] markets like Saragosa where there is a [21:42] [21:42] real uh mobility issue public [21:45] [21:45] transportation is sparse if you go there [21:47] [21:47] at certain times of the day you can't [21:49] [21:49] find a cab there's there's this Motors [21:50] [21:51] and whatnot but there's nothing else in [21:52] [21:52] between at that time it was the case [21:54] [21:54] so there it made a lot of sense but in a [21:56] [21:57] city like Barcelona where you have [21:58] [21:58] um you know millions of tourists it is a [22:01] [22:01] public nuisance I give you that it is a [22:03] [22:03] public nuisance right so free floating [22:06] [22:06] uh it can create problems it it is yeah [22:10] [22:10] it does create problems and I'll be you [22:11] [22:11] know you have to be honest and [22:12] [22:12] acknowledge that so and especially [22:14] [22:14] around you know dense neighborhoods like [22:16] [22:16] the gothic and so on yeah it's not nice [22:19] [22:19] right so people zipping around these [22:20] [22:21] things [22:22] [22:22] um yeah things it hadn't been proven out [22:24] [22:24] uh there were there was a lot to be [22:27] [22:27] desired was there some specific incident [22:29] [22:29] uh no do you remember like somebody I [22:32] [22:32] don't know falling dying somebody's [22:33] [22:33] dying on a no not on so fortunately you [22:36] [22:36] know but there was one incident where [22:39] [22:39] someone was hurt uh but nothing no no [22:42] [22:42] fatalities as I recall as far as I was I [22:46] [22:46] was I was involved but what did the the [22:48] [22:48] city hall uh argument what was it so the [22:50] [22:50] argument was [22:52] [22:52] um this is not approved no one uh it's [22:56] [22:56] it needs there needs to be a proper [22:57] [22:57] process uh it needs to be evaluated in [23:00] [23:00] terms of safety in terms of all of that [23:02] [23:02] we went through the process of [23:04] [23:04] registering each one of these vehicles [23:06] [23:06] with the city hall there was a process [23:07] [23:07] that we that we that we fulfilled a new [23:09] [23:09] process because it was a new process a [23:11] [23:11] new process but we registered them just [23:13] [23:13] like all the other Mobility operators [23:14] [23:14] like the bicycles yeah so we had the [23:16] [23:16] motorbikes exactly we had the QR code [23:18] [23:18] and everything uh so we we fulfilled all [23:21] [23:21] those requirements but you know it's a [23:23] [23:23] political thing right so you can't [23:24] [23:24] influence it uh you you do your best you [23:27] [23:27] work around [23:28] [23:28] using the experience that we built here [23:30] [23:30] in Barcelona and and the and the [23:33] [23:33] uh the density and the number of rides [23:36] [23:36] um we were able to drive operational [23:39] [23:39] excellence in terms of building a [23:41] [23:42] capability of maintaining the fleet [23:43] [23:43] building Partnerships with you know [23:45] [23:45] 3pl's third-party Logistics providers uh [23:49] [23:49] building that capability and exporting [23:51] [23:51] it to other markets such as [23:53] [23:53] all of these other places that maybe [23:56] [23:56] eventually ended up operating in through [23:58] [23:58] public tenders so taking this experience [24:01] [24:01] building working closely with building a [24:04] [24:04] legal strategy having a very strong [24:07] [24:07] legal team that was enabling all of [24:10] [24:10] these other cities to you know come up [24:11] [24:11] with a public policy around [24:12] [24:12] Transportation participating in those [24:14] [24:14] rfps and building long-term [24:16] [24:16] relationships with those cities so it it [24:19] [24:19] to that end it really helped but it was [24:22] [24:22] it's a shame that we couldn't operate in [24:25] [24:25] your home City in the home City exactly [24:27] [24:27] but you know I mean it is a challenge I [24:28] [24:28] remember I was a heavy user of Ruby for [24:30] [24:30] a while because they were the fastest [24:32] [24:32] anything most available [24:33] [24:33] ways of transportation around me but I [24:37] [24:37] remember going to Paris with you [24:38] [24:38] actually uh in 2018 do you remember I [24:41] [24:41] was shocked like the the the the Seas of [24:45] [24:45] scooters Fallen everywhere in the middle [24:47] [24:47] of the of the sidewalks and same in [24:51] [24:51] London there was nothing compared to [24:53] [24:53] China and the bicycles [24:55] [24:55] but it wasn't a pleasant experience like [24:57] [24:57] you're in the center of Paris and my [24:59] [24:59] feeling is like what's all this crap [25:00] [25:00] here in the middle yeah right like [25:02] [25:02] that's that's that was my and I want [25:04] [25:04] tools like this but it is a challenge to [25:06] [25:06] the city no but there needs to be a way [25:07] [25:07] to solve it but a great point because [25:09] [25:09] what happened in Paris specifically [25:11] [25:11] citing this example they did a [25:13] [25:13] referendum right uh six months ago and [25:15] [25:15] and the citizens voted against removing [25:18] [25:18] so they want they want the scooters no [25:20] [25:20] they voted against suitors ah okay so [25:22] [25:22] they don't want anything yeah so they [25:24] [25:24] didn't referendum About Scooters yeah [25:25] [25:25] wow yeah [25:30] [25:30] [Music] [25:33] [25:33] it's great for haters but [25:37] [25:37] it says we can open the box of democracy [25:39] [25:39] now but the consequence is that you know [25:41] [25:41] Paris is not going to have scooters they [25:44] [25:44] know this sort of uh free-floating uh [25:48] [25:48] Mobility options is going to be gone [25:49] [25:49] bicycles bicycles will continue it's [25:52] [25:52] kind of weird no why they're not that [25:53] [25:53] different they have two wheels and the [25:56] [25:56] problem is the sidewalk no if they are [25:57] [25:57] feeling the sidewalk yeah [26:01] [26:02] no yeah the scooters right but in a [26:04] [26:04] dense City like Barcelona and Paris and [26:07] [26:07] so on where you just don't have the [26:08] [26:08] public infrastructure it's very hard [26:10] [26:10] yeah but for example Barcelona got the [26:12] [26:12] the circulation right like I think we [26:15] [26:15] are one of the fastest growing cities in [26:18] [26:18] Europe in number of uh bicycle Lanes I [26:21] [26:21] don't know how you call them yeah so [26:22] [26:22] that part I think we kind of got right [26:23] [26:23] the problem is where do you leave the [26:25] [26:25] stuff like you're not going to take it [26:27] [26:27] home when people live in tiny Apartments [26:29] [26:29] so it's a good idea to rent it and share [26:31] [26:31] it but then where do we put them very [26:33] [26:33] popular in Barcelona but for some reason [26:35] [26:35] scooters are very hated yeah but not [26:38] [26:38] only the Public Services also the [26:39] [26:39] private scooters are kind of forbidden [26:41] [26:41] or anything no no you have to go in [26:43] [26:43] particular places you have to wear yeah [26:45] [26:45] speaking you're not supposed to ride on [26:48] [26:48] um on the aceras so on the side yeah [26:52] [26:52] but but yeah practically speaking you [26:55] [26:55] see people zipping by you so there's a [26:58] [26:58] nuisance Factor right so I'm not [26:59] [26:59] surprised that there's been a huge [27:01] [27:01] backlash and so coming back to to rebi [27:04] [27:04] uh scooters were just one mode of [27:07] [27:07] Transport so we had bicycles for you [27:09] [27:09] foreign the plan obviously was to [27:12] [27:12] include other modes of Transport like [27:13] [27:13] Motors scooters did you get there uh [27:16] [27:16] eventually yes yeah okay yeah so since [27:19] [27:19] they disappeared from Barcelona I never [27:20] [27:20] knew yeah so I [27:22] [27:22] um did it so it was basically [27:25] [27:25] um a different kind of model a franchise [27:27] [27:27] model okay you know um [27:30] [27:30] franchisees use the platform to to [27:34] [27:34] basically offer their offerings so yes [27:36] [27:36] and and if there was not no regulation [27:39] [27:39] problem would it be a good business [27:41] [27:41] because somehow I don't know the the all [27:44] [27:44] these players that appeared they went [27:45] [27:45] dying one by one and yeah so you know [27:49] [27:49] there has to be some some problem so [27:52] [27:52] there's space so there's very few uh [27:54] [27:54] operators left from that original cohort [27:56] [27:56] of American companies right so like the [27:59] [27:59] limes and limes still is still one of [28:02] [28:02] the dominant players but practically [28:04] [28:04] gone uh and then in Europe you have uh [28:07] [28:07] the Swedish Warrior which is still got a [28:10] [28:10] dominant presence in the nodding Sierra [28:11] [28:11] tier and boy I think are emerged or [28:14] [28:14] something to actually in fact yeah so [28:15] [28:15] yeah they're they're still relevant uh [28:18] [28:18] and the vast majority of [28:20] [28:20] other players have disappeared right or [28:23] [28:23] practically disappearing so it's a tough [28:26] [28:26] model uh uh it's [28:28] [28:28] we had the right instincts to invest in [28:31] [28:31] in and build a capability ground up from [28:33] [28:33] the hardware and so on [28:35] [28:35] um so to that end while it lasted it was [28:37] [28:37] it was good [28:39] [28:39] um [28:40] [28:40] but it's it's the unit economics are [28:42] [28:42] very strong a very hard way because the [28:45] [28:45] cost to serve is is very is very high [28:48] [28:48] the logistics is not cheap so the cost [28:50] [28:50] is what uh 1000 Euros a scooter no no [28:55] [28:55] um so [28:58] [28:58] um [28:59] [28:59] yes but we were able to do it for [29:01] [29:01] significantly less less than a thousand [29:03] [29:03] yeah 500 more or less 500 scooter then [29:07] [29:07] there's a maintenance so the maintenance [29:09] [29:09] is very is is problematic so maintenance [29:11] [29:11] being recharging so if you have a [29:13] [29:13] replaceable replaceable batteries it [29:15] [29:15] drops significantly but that adds on a [29:18] [29:18] lot of cost and you need people actual [29:20] [29:20] humans who will change the battery [29:21] [29:21] around the city also operationally is [29:23] [29:23] expensive uh you need to move the actual [29:25] [29:25] scooters to the point because there's [29:27] [29:27] typically a start point and end point [29:28] [29:28] and they're not the same yeah yeah but [29:30] [29:30] that also depends on the usage no so the [29:32] [29:32] usage has a percentage of cost for [29:34] [29:34] repairing and recharging and [29:36] [29:36] redistribution right so ultimately it [29:38] [29:38] comes down to uh so we have to be able [29:40] [29:40] to redistribute the fleet uh to certain [29:43] [29:43] points in where there's demand is going [29:45] [29:45] to be right so if you take uh what [29:48] [29:48] happened let's say in the peak months [29:50] [29:50] between July to September [29:53] [29:53] eighty percent of the fleet would be in [29:55] [29:55] uh in the Benoit area so you need to [29:57] [29:57] move those things back to uh what does [30:01] [30:01] these people do they just stay in the [30:02] [30:02] beach [30:03] [30:03] uh or I suppose yeah so it's just [30:05] [30:05] congregation they just get drunk and [30:07] [30:07] stay there [30:09] [30:09] so it can be frustrating in that sense [30:11] [30:11] from a user perspective if you don't [30:13] [30:13] distribute uh so we we did a decent job [30:16] [30:16] but that was not cost efficient we [30:18] [30:18] didn't crack that model there were [30:20] [30:20] algorithms that incentivated that people [30:22] [30:22] would take yeah from one place to [30:25] [30:25] another yeah so we we did that uh but [30:29] [30:29] you know the start and stop was very [30:31] [30:31] frustrating right so we didn't have [30:33] [30:33] enough operational data to be able to [30:35] [30:35] really optimize those models to be able [30:37] [30:37] to drive real value because you know you [30:39] [30:39] one week you'd be on one week you'd be [30:41] [30:41] off uh this cat and mouse with a city [30:43] [30:43] which is frustrating it uh it didn't [30:45] [30:45] help uh so you mean start and stop in [30:48] [30:48] terms of Regulation yeah that the police [30:50] [30:50] would suddenly yeah stop people right I [30:53] [30:53] remember Cesar telling me like police is [30:55] [30:55] stopping people driving uh riding on a [30:58] [30:58] rebi or other as good there's suddenly [31:01] [31:01] one week it's like don't don't get on [31:02] [31:02] one or you might get in trouble and then [31:03] [31:03] next week he was okay and they would be [31:05] [31:05] fine [31:06] [31:06] if you were driving I never got one [31:08] [31:08] there were people who were fined yes [31:10] [31:10] really yeah there were people who find [31:12] [31:12] she's like as a Founder which is hard [31:14] [31:14] enough then again fighting against the [31:17] [31:17] police like on top of everything [31:18] [31:18] fighting against the market and fighting [31:19] [31:19] against the place it was challenging uh [31:22] [31:22] to say the least [31:24] [31:24] um anyway so ready was [31:27] [31:27] um a great experience in that so you you [31:29] [31:29] left after a couple three years [31:32] [31:32] something like that so yeah I uh two [31:35] [31:35] years in I left my operational role so I [31:37] [31:37] uh I exited I so it was also [31:42] [31:42] um the timing also had to do with when [31:44] [31:44] we went to the franchise model around [31:46] [31:46] the pandemics time frame uh I opted out [31:49] [31:49] and it was also a combination of factors [31:52] [31:52] right so Andreas the CEO and co-founder [31:56] [31:56] of two had come back from linear he was [31:59] [31:59] in Norway getting ready to start [32:01] [32:01] something up we had a couple of chats to [32:04] [32:04] build something that would become too [32:07] [32:07] was really interesting and just you know [32:09] [32:09] I'd like to touch upon this and it'll be [32:11] [32:11] a perfect segue to get into why two came [32:13] [32:13] about and what was the problem we were [32:15] [32:15] solving so in our experience at uh [32:17] [32:17] linear Lineo is a Marketplace uh [32:20] [32:20] Merchant right so we were selling stuff [32:21] [32:21] on behalf of merchants and about 20 of [32:24] [32:24] our clientele clients where business is [32:27] [32:27] making purchases on our platform and [32:29] [32:29] typically these businesses required to [32:32] [32:32] make or to make purchases on invoice [32:35] [32:35] right so with some deferred mode of [32:38] [32:38] payment some credit [32:39] [32:39] and as big as linear was it was not a [32:42] [32:42] core competency we could not credit on [32:44] [32:44] the right we could not [32:45] [32:45] have a verify identity issue invoices [32:48] [32:48] follow-up collections all of that it was [32:50] [32:50] a huge challenge [32:52] [32:52] and we were losing a lot of sales a [32:53] [32:53] typical experience of some of these [32:56] [32:56] customers would they would come into the [32:57] [32:57] you know checkout page and they'd they'd [32:59] [33:00] see pay with credit card pay with cash [33:02] [33:02] they pick up the phone call customer [33:04] [33:04] service how can I pay on invoice I want [33:06] [33:06] to buy 50 TVs [33:07] [33:07] uh you know pay in 30 days 60 days in 30 [33:10] [33:10] days we try to establish some of the [33:12] [33:12] sales would be loosen so that's [33:14] [33:14] the point the the the challenge that we [33:16] [33:16] are trying to solve or we are solving [33:18] [33:18] here today with two [33:20] [33:20] and you know that resonated really well [33:22] [33:22] with me early stage let's get this going [33:24] [33:24] working again with Andreas on on this [33:27] [33:27] was amazing so [33:29] [33:29] uh it was you know tough decision to [33:31] [33:31] make to leave rabi uh that was very [33:34] [33:34] understanding can you can you share with [33:36] [33:36] us [33:37] [33:37] um because this is something that [33:38] [33:38] happens in startups when founders start [33:40] [33:40] a company with all the dreams and [33:42] [33:42] illusion of what's going to happen and [33:44] [33:44] then at some point things go south or [33:45] [33:45] things don't go as expected and then [33:47] [33:47] they have this conversation yeah so how [33:49] [33:49] do you manage this conversation with [33:50] [33:50] your co-founders yeah so with a lot of [33:53] [33:53] uh guilt [33:55] [33:55] uh and uh and stress obviously [33:59] [33:59] um so it was a tough time for the [34:00] [34:00] business it was you know the pandemic [34:02] [34:02] was on uh the business was slowly [34:04] [34:04] getting back on its feet [34:05] [34:05] I had this thing uh this was precisely [34:09] [34:09] three years ago so September in 2020. [34:14] [34:14] um so yeah I I was clear in what I [34:16] [34:16] wanted and I was also uh at a point in [34:19] [34:19] my life uh where I wanted to put myself [34:21] [34:21] and my family forward right first the [34:24] [34:24] review experience was great and where I [34:27] [34:27] was within the company what I could [34:28] [34:28] offer in terms of regulatory uh aspects [34:32] [34:32] of things fundraising uh and so on I [34:35] [34:35] wasn't adding a lot of value there [34:36] [34:36] personally so it was a reckoning now [34:38] [34:38] look I could do better somewhere else or [34:40] [34:40] I could continue here and I think you [34:42] [34:42] know when I had that conversation with [34:44] [34:44] pep it was hard but he was understanding [34:47] [34:47] you know this is ultimately a where your [34:50] [34:50] heart is is what you do and I stayed on [34:52] [34:52] in a you know advisory capacity uh [34:56] [34:56] beyond that but I I [34:58] [34:58] I removed myself from a day-to-day [35:01] [35:01] um starting you know 2020 September [35:03] [35:03] October [35:04] [35:04] and then around January when things [35:07] [35:07] really started picking up with two I was [35:09] [35:09] fully out so fully out as in also [35:12] [35:12] selling you shares or you stayed a [35:15] [35:15] shareholder I stayed as a shareholder uh [35:17] [35:17] until [35:19] [35:19] um until the the acquisition uh by Seoul [35:23] [35:23] uh or House of lithium [35:25] [35:25] which was basically they let us use a at [35:29] [35:29] rebbe this was just after I I left so [35:31] [35:31] they were one of the biggest investors [35:32] [35:33] the Lead Series investor is the one that [35:35] [35:35] offered to acquire the company correct [35:36] [35:36] yeah that offered uh signed well yeah I [35:40] [35:40] mean that's something I wanted to ask [35:41] [35:41] about because for but but then in this [35:43] [35:43] series hey if there was a secondary and [35:45] [35:45] is where you left no I I didn't settle [35:47] [35:47] at the series a so I sold uh before [35:50] [35:50] before the acquisition just before the [35:52] [35:52] acquisition [35:53] [35:53] okay and then how did what happened with [35:55] [35:55] Robbie yeah exactly between the news [35:57] [35:57] here it was recently in the news yeah so [36:00] [36:00] it's um it's still in in litigation so [36:03] [36:03] in the US in the US uh because this is a [36:06] [36:06] Delaware Corporation and uh the last [36:09] [36:09] outcome was that you know it we need to [36:12] [36:12] basically go to trial again and yeah [36:14] [36:14] that's where it is so this house of [36:16] [36:16] lithium came to rabi and said I want to [36:18] [36:18] buy you or Robbie went to them and say [36:20] [36:20] we want to sell [36:22] [36:22] I'm not on on top of the details uh [36:24] [36:24] there but basically they were one of the [36:27] [36:27] investors right so lead investor with a [36:29] [36:29] with a significant stake in the business [36:30] [36:30] already prior to the acquisition and [36:33] [36:33] from what I understand their strategy [36:34] [36:34] was to build a constellation of Brands [36:37] [36:37] right so around probability uh battery [36:40] [36:40] management uh and so on and ready was [36:43] [36:43] fit into the the picture as one one [36:45] [36:45] piece of that puzzle uh and they had [36:47] [36:47] acquired another cost another company in [36:49] [36:49] the battery space uh and so on and this [36:51] [36:51] was basically the plan to float uh an [36:54] [36:54] entity that gets uh on the on the [36:57] [36:57] Canadian Stock Exchange [36:59] [36:59] So to that end the review deal would be [37:02] [37:02] you know review would be acquired wholly [37:04] [37:04] uh by house [37:06] [37:06] uh yeah like um you know cash to pay out [37:10] [37:10] the the equity holders uh and and some [37:13] [37:13] Surplus for for for some early for the [37:17] [37:17] management team or exactly and that was [37:19] [37:19] basically the team but it was a good a [37:20] [37:20] good outcome for the founders and for [37:22] [37:22] the investors if it had gone through [37:24] [37:24] from what I understand it would have [37:25] [37:25] been a fantastic uh outcome for uh the [37:28] [37:28] shareholders acquisition yeah because [37:30] [37:30] they and for the company that would [37:32] [37:32] survive yeah yeah but you know the way [37:35] [37:35] things ended up is that uh what happened [37:37] [37:37] what what's the Tipping Point [37:39] [37:39] so litigation is expensive but why is [37:41] [37:41] there litigation no what happened [37:43] [37:43] probably is that the market Fall so the [37:46] [37:46] world financial Market there's many [37:47] [37:47] things right so [37:49] [37:49] one is uh [37:51] [37:51] yes so the company needed a response [37:53] [37:53] right so either through an acquisition [37:55] [37:55] or through the private markets uh as a [37:59] [37:59] extension to the series A or B or [38:00] [38:00] whatever we have we had a term sheet [38:02] [38:02] that was executed and signed uh not term [38:05] [38:05] sheet a sale document everything done so [38:07] [38:07] the transaction the transaction was [38:08] [38:08] assigned [38:09] [38:09] typically in a transaction document like [38:12] [38:12] this you have like 30 days to wire the [38:13] [38:13] money and stuff like that a portion of [38:15] [38:15] the funds were wired as well a portion [38:17] [38:17] of the funds was wired yeah a small [38:19] [38:19] portion yeah [38:21] [38:21] so the deal was had happened in the [38:24] [38:24] second the second wire never came the [38:27] [38:27] The Joint statement the press release [38:29] [38:30] was will happen with them so there was a [38:33] [38:33] there was an article crunch everything [38:34] [38:34] yeah that's true so everything went out [38:36] [38:36] and then yeah it was like uh I suppose a [38:39] [38:39] Twitter Elon moment on their end [38:42] [38:42] um and they they've done their best to [38:44] [38:44] get out of it so they decided to [38:47] [38:47] walk back the acquisition yeah excited [38:51] [38:51] legally yeah and that's basically where [38:53] [38:53] we are today it's uh that sucks [38:55] [38:55] you have a Twitter I mean I don't lost [38:59] [38:59] yeah let's say no yeah so I don't know [39:02] [39:02] that I know don't know the document but [39:03] [39:03] depends on how it's written especially [39:06] [39:06] in the US well it looks quite effective [39:08] [39:08] explicitly said he doesn't want anything [39:10] [39:10] diligence like he signed the worst [39:12] [39:12] possible contract apparently yeah but it [39:15] [39:15] should be quite effective in the US [39:17] [39:17] maybe in Spain that could be two years [39:19] [39:19] but or more or more yeah so you know for [39:22] [39:22] practical purposes there is a [39:24] [39:24] There's Hope [39:26] [39:26] um yeah yeah I think you know that [39:28] [39:28] they're forced to pay and then but how [39:30] [39:30] can that we hope I mean the company [39:32] [39:32] cannot survive like people cannot stay [39:34] [39:34] waiting for money to arrive no that's [39:37] [39:37] true so things are uh where they are [39:39] [39:39] today because of that because of that [39:41] [39:41] reason yeah [39:42] [39:42] I'm sure there's an infinite detail [39:43] [39:43] right there [39:45] [39:45] the thing is you went then uh you met [39:48] [39:48] Andreas again uh with it was somebody [39:50] [39:50] you you liked when you worked with him [39:52] [39:52] and and you felt like that was a good [39:55] [39:55] opportunity for you [39:56] [39:56] um and and what and the beach was what [39:59] [39:59] you said before no solving this problem [40:01] [40:01] that you're covered in basically what is [40:04] [40:04] two we offer an API payment method for [40:06] [40:06] API based payment method for B2B so B2B [40:09] [40:09] specific you can simplify it by saying [40:11] [40:11] it's a buy now pay later solution for [40:13] [40:13] specifically for B2B so what that [40:15] [40:15] entails is we enable [40:17] [40:17] um businesses that make purchases [40:21] [40:21] so all people that make purchases on [40:23] [40:23] behalf of your business so let's take [40:25] [40:25] the use case of factorial purchasing [40:27] [40:27] computers from Apple or uh or Amazon [40:30] [40:30] right so you have an account a trade [40:33] [40:33] account with one of these companies [40:34] [40:34] that's a real case we do that yeah so uh [40:37] [40:37] and uh and two basically offers a fund [40:41] [40:41] fully funded invoice solution to Amazon [40:43] [40:43] to fund [40:45] [40:45] um the purchases on behalf of factory so [40:47] [40:47] we don't pay Apple you pay Apple correct [40:50] [40:50] and then we pay you correct and this is [40:52] [40:52] an API only so I didn't even know that [40:55] [40:55] you exist Apple provides this to us so [40:58] [40:58] it depends on the operating model and [41:00] [41:00] where we operate we are not a white [41:02] [41:02] label solution per se so we exist as a [41:05] [41:05] payment so the financing agreement is [41:06] [41:06] with you the the end exactly so we uh [41:11] [41:11] help the merchant delegate all of the [41:13] [41:13] collections uh the risk the the credit [41:17] [41:17] and the fraud risk to us so it's closer [41:20] [41:20] to Atlanta or an affirm yeah the [41:22] [41:22] difference is the buyer is specifically [41:23] [41:23] B2B exactly so it's a much larger what [41:27] [41:27] changes product space when the buyer is [41:28] [41:28] a B2B [41:29] [41:29] for from whose perspective from the [41:32] [41:32] business perspective yeah the risk is a [41:35] [41:35] lot harder to assess because you know [41:36] [41:36] you don't have uh credit bureau [41:38] [41:38] information so it's a capability to [41:41] [41:41] build that we we have now three years [41:42] [41:42] under our belt doing it in three markets [41:44] [41:44] do you have algorithms or data or [41:46] [41:46] something we've built when I put [41:48] [41:48] factorial ink which is not a real name [41:50] [41:50] that I put their company name then you [41:51] [41:51] know How likely you are to get the money [41:53] [41:53] back yeah exactly so we we built we've [41:57] [41:57] invested and make that happen [41:59] [41:59] um so we give you [42:01] [42:01] um a credit worthiness score and then [42:03] [42:03] you know right away whether you can [42:04] [42:04] continue with the purchase or not and in [42:06] [42:06] some cases the merchant has the [42:08] [42:08] capability to show whether the payment [42:11] [42:11] method is relevant for you or not [42:12] [42:12] they're factoring now so factoring so [42:16] [42:16] factoring happens in a post sale context [42:19] [42:19] where the issue or the invoice is [42:21] [42:21] created and then you sell the invoice so [42:24] [42:24] what we're doing is real-time decision [42:25] [42:25] making right so we're doing it at the [42:27] [42:27] point of sale so yes it is factoring but [42:30] [42:30] it's factoring with a Twist the invoice [42:32] [42:32] in the user experience though it's a [42:35] [42:35] much faster the risk ass salesman and [42:37] [42:37] everything it's the same thing is the [42:39] [42:39] seller no who decides to do that so I [42:41] [42:41] sell you something expensive you're [42:43] [42:43] going to pay me 90 days and I go to the [42:45] [42:45] bank and I say I want the money now and [42:47] [42:47] the bank gives it to me the seller no [42:48] [42:48] that's another thing that is factoring [42:51] [42:51] factoring is not a seller yeah that's [42:54] [42:54] how I understand factoring it's a seller [42:56] [42:56] who gets this so your account payables [42:57] [42:57] right so your account receivable you can [42:59] [42:59] sell your I want to get the money [43:00] [43:00] earlier exactly exactly well obviously [43:03] [43:03] at a cost for me so you partner with [43:05] [43:05] Apple [43:06] [43:06] no so that would be great uh we no so [43:10] [43:10] our uh so in Sweden we operate with uh [43:14] [43:14] net on net which is one of the largest [43:15] [43:15] uh e-commerce uh players in the region [43:17] [43:17] in Norway the authorized Apple [43:21] [43:21] distributor is uh office to as a payment [43:24] [43:24] method uh so we service everything from [43:28] [43:28] SAS consultancies physical Goods uh [43:31] [43:31] purchasing [43:32] [43:32] and uh and in the construction space as [43:34] [43:34] well so marketplaces are also an option [43:37] [43:37] are you judge who [43:39] [43:39] we charge the margin so no matter [43:42] [43:42] so it's it's it's exactly like offering [43:45] [43:45] uh later no so think of it like you have [43:49] [43:49] you're selling a product on your site [43:50] [43:51] right and you offer credit card as a [43:54] [43:54] payment method so you're basically we're [43:55] [43:55] we're basically the payment method [43:58] [43:58] instead of you paying stripe you're [44:00] [44:00] paying us and you have a parameter of [44:02] [44:02] better conversion exactly much higher [44:04] [44:04] conversion what are they paying for [44:05] [44:05] specifically for B2B right so so back to [44:08] [44:08] your case in linear so coming so when [44:10] [44:10] they wanted 40 TVs and they didn't want [44:11] [44:12] to pay up front they didn't buy if they [44:14] [44:14] lost their sales it's a lost lost sale [44:16] [44:16] opportunity that you that you that you [44:18] [44:18] don't lose [44:20] [44:20] um then the operational complexity right [44:22] [44:22] most businesses are not in the should [44:25] [44:25] not be in the business of credit [44:27] [44:27] underwriting Collections and so on right [44:29] [44:29] so it's operationally complex there's [44:31] [44:31] overhead that is outsourced to two so [44:33] [44:33] two basically does all of that on behalf [44:35] [44:35] of those customers so if the customer [44:37] [44:37] doesn't pay [44:38] [44:38] it's always your problem it's my it's [44:39] [44:39] our problem exactly so you're very [44:41] [44:41] motivated to do the correct underwriting [44:44] [44:44] exactly exactly not just for your [44:45] [44:45] customer but because otherwise you take [44:47] [44:47] this yeah we take the hit of course so [44:48] [44:48] this is a capability that uh what what [44:51] [44:51] is what's the price what's the interest [44:52] [44:52] rate so there's no interest so it's not [44:54] [44:54] interest rate based it's basically a [44:56] [44:56] transaction fee service yeah it's a [44:58] [44:58] transaction fee in interest so think of [45:01] [45:01] it I will convert it as an interest if I [45:03] [45:03] would be a seller so think of it as the [45:05] [45:05] it's on par with the transaction fee [45:08] [45:08] that you would pay strike or for an Amex [45:10] [45:10] transaction right so like a two each [45:12] [45:12] percent to each percent yeah okay on on [45:15] [45:15] a 15 to 30 day invoice so if if it's a [45:18] [45:18] different product which is basically [45:19] [45:19] installments which we could do anywhere [45:20] [45:21] between three to 12 months it will be [45:22] [45:22] higher and how do you collect the money [45:24] [45:24] how do they pay you [45:25] [45:25] um you cannot pay stripe no yeah exactly [45:28] [45:28] it's wire transfer why transfer or uh [45:30] [45:30] and then you have an army of collections [45:32] [45:32] agents that are calling [45:34] [45:34] um you know so we're pretty efficient so [45:36] [45:36] we're in the northern switch I guess [45:37] [45:37] yeah [45:40] [45:40] so we do have a small collections team [45:42] [45:42] which is like one or two people uh it's [45:44] [45:44] very small for a business that only does [45:46] [45:46] this basically yeah yeah and the UK as [45:48] [45:48] well um so it's basically UK should be [45:50] [45:50] maybe more challenging so our basically [45:53] [45:53] a Collections Unit is about three people [45:54] [45:54] but it's it's highly organized automated [45:57] [45:57] so our bank operations [45:59] [45:59] um [46:01] [46:01] yes uh there are it's a small it's a [46:04] [46:04] small percentage but you know in in this [46:06] [46:06] business what you do is you don't you [46:08] [46:08] build up you build up the confidence [46:09] [46:09] right so there are some first time there [46:12] [46:12] is there is first party fraud uh but [46:14] [46:14] it's a very small percentage we don't [46:16] [46:16] take big risks and there is an identity [46:19] [46:19] verification piece associated with with [46:20] [46:21] the buyer experience you don't take big [46:22] [46:22] marginal drift invoice by invoice but in [46:25] [46:25] some you're thinking another place yeah [46:26] [46:26] but it's Diversified right it's across [46:28] [46:28] Industries it's across multiple how much [46:30] [46:30] money is Lent out right now for example [46:32] [46:32] this is the number you track uh roughly [46:34] [46:34] is it like in the millions tens of [46:36] [46:36] millions so we're transacting in the [46:38] [46:38] almost double digits uh volume per month [46:42] [46:42] on a monthly basis so eight nine [46:43] [46:43] whatever seven eight nine million no [46:45] [46:45] slightly more than that okay we're on [46:47] [46:47] track to basically 2x uh 2.5 x what we [46:51] [46:51] did in 2022 okay the the demand is that [46:53] [46:53] growth is there and we're and you said [46:56] [46:56] Norway [46:57] [46:57] Sweden Norway Sweden and UK and the UK [47:00] [47:00] is a no-brainer I mean if you're giving [47:02] [47:02] money to the people that's always a man [47:04] [47:04] the question is how can you build a [47:07] [47:07] business a sustainable business [47:08] [47:08] sustainable business indeed so and do [47:11] [47:11] you go to SMB or you go to large [47:12] [47:12] Enterprise it's totally different risk [47:14] [47:14] so yes so we are we we had to start at [47:17] [47:17] the lower end which is small small and [47:19] [47:19] medium business [47:21] [47:21] the risk is there but you know if you [47:23] [47:23] build uh so think about it this way [47:24] [47:24] right so who's taking the risk today is [47:26] [47:26] the merchant if they don't offer any [47:28] [47:28] Services any any buy now pay later or [47:31] [47:31] let's say they are just extending [47:33] [47:33] invoice or net terms on invoice they're [47:35] [47:35] taking the risk [47:37] [47:37] the sales are growing [47:38] [47:39] and what they're doing is basically [47:40] [47:40] forwarding us good customers there's a [47:43] [47:43] need there's a digital good or bad [47:45] [47:45] customer good customer so the good [47:46] [47:46] customer they can do it themselves yeah [47:49] [47:49] but they're taking so nobody give good [47:51] [47:51] customer but there's a working capital [47:52] [47:52] issue right so if you if they're going [47:55] [47:55] to pay you in 30 days what we're doing [47:57] [47:57] is we pay you right away so there is a [47:59] [47:59] valuable position there okay there's no [48:01] [48:01] collections they don't have to have a [48:02] [48:02] team running after but why don't they [48:04] [48:04] give you the bad customers too if they [48:05] [48:05] get paid today sure of course [48:12] [48:12] we give us customers exactly so good [48:15] [48:15] about [48:19] [48:19] has to pay for the collection people the [48:22] [48:22] risk that you are taking and the whole [48:24] [48:24] business [48:25] [48:25] so it's a high volume business it's a [48:27] [48:27] high volume business it's like payments [48:28] [48:28] right payments is um it's a high scale [48:30] [48:30] business you have to you have to be [48:32] [48:32] operating you need to get to the [48:33] [48:33] billions yeah and that's for there to be [48:35] [48:35] a business yeah that's um that's the [48:37] [48:37] part we're on uh the trajectory of our [48:39] [48:39] own and uh so far so good so [48:42] [48:42] so and and you said you it raised the [48:45] [48:45] reason it raised money and yeah so we uh [48:48] [48:48] so we raised our initial round [48:51] [48:51] um in 2021 so a good time yeah so [48:55] [48:55] precede uh uh which was led by uh [48:58] [48:58] Sequoia and local Globe uh and [49:01] [49:01] Visionaries club and then we followed [49:03] [49:03] that up in the summer with a with a seed [49:05] [49:05] round and then a series a round [49:08] [49:08] uh we we closed it last October uh [49:12] [49:12] anymore yeah but you know it's uh the [49:15] [49:15] timing was uh could have been worse but [49:18] [49:18] we did we did well in that sense uh did [49:21] [49:21] you race in total [49:22] [49:22] so the most recent round was about 20 [49:23] [49:23] million [49:25] [49:25] uh USD so in total we're at about 28. [49:28] [49:28] the company legally what is it so we're [49:31] [49:31] headquartered and we're headquartered [49:33] [49:33] and Incorporated in Norway so it's [49:35] [49:35] Norway it's a Norwegian and the team so [49:37] [49:37] the team is distributed between uh Oslo [49:40] [49:40] which is where uh there's about 20 [49:42] [49:42] people there there's another 20 in [49:44] [49:44] London Sweden has a small presence about [49:47] [49:47] five or six people and we have a tech [49:49] [49:49] Outpost in in Glasgow uh so we built a [49:52] [49:52] small team there about 70 people [49:54] [49:54] and then our distributed Workforce [49:56] [49:56] across other other markets but that's a [49:58] [49:58] small smaller proportion of uh of [50:01] [50:01] employees or remote where do you see [50:04] [50:04] your future [50:05] [50:05] so um [50:07] [50:07] in the next three to five years being [50:10] [50:10] one of the largest B2B Payment Solutions [50:13] [50:13] uh with a huge presence in in the US [50:16] [50:16] just which is the next big market for us [50:18] [50:18] to capture [50:20] [50:20] um yeah so processing in in the billions [50:24] [50:24] and of course being contribution margin [50:27] [50:27] uh positive not profitable yeah that's [50:31] [50:31] uh that's the goal working towards that [50:33] [50:33] and yeah let's see so the Tailwinds are [50:35] [50:35] there you know their businesses need [50:37] [50:37] working capital relief and that's [50:39] [50:39] something we do really well and you roll [50:41] [50:41] specifically yeah so that's a vault uh [50:44] [50:44] again I've done many things at two so [50:46] [50:46] started in the product role uh [50:48] [50:48] transitioned into [50:50] [50:50] taking care of all things uh people and [50:53] [50:53] investor relations so in internal and [50:54] [50:54] external in that context [50:56] [50:56] today I'm in the process I I don't know [50:59] [50:59] if I mentioned it earlier so I'm in the [51:01] [51:01] process of transitioning out of an [51:02] [51:02] operating role at two [51:04] [51:04] um we'll do that over the next four or [51:07] [51:07] five months the reason being primarily [51:10] [51:10] I've spent three years being one of the [51:12] [51:12] key members of the team working remotely [51:14] [51:14] from Barcelona the company is at a stage [51:17] [51:17] where you know we require a physical [51:19] [51:19] presence in either Oslo or London for [51:22] [51:22] someone in my way I mean I'm very much [51:25] [51:25] for repeating yeah so why would you say [51:28] [51:28] it requires for me personally it would [51:30] [51:30] be uh for me to be more engaged to be on [51:33] [51:33] stuff on a day-to-day basis and I think [51:34] [51:34] you know you have a better velocity when [51:37] [51:37] it comes to decision making higher [51:39] [51:39] engagement so on [51:41] [51:41] um and for me it's very hard to do that [51:42] [51:42] uh from where I am here one one thought [51:45] [51:45] I mean obviously not to you because [51:48] [51:48] you've seen early stage many times but I [51:50] [51:50] think many people romanticize early [51:52] [51:52] stage and I've had many people that have [51:54] [51:54] been at larger startups and they say [51:56] [51:57] what they like is the early stage and [51:58] [51:58] then they go to the early stage and they [52:00] [52:00] cannot stand the uncertainty the chaos [52:02] [52:02] the lack of resources the scrappiness [52:04] [52:04] the constant fear of death so obviously [52:06] [52:06] you've seen that plenty of times yeah [52:08] [52:08] especially from private already [52:11] [52:11] exceptions [52:15] [52:15] it wasn't so dramatic as death but there [52:18] [52:18] were tough times right uh and yeah so [52:22] [52:22] your people romanticize it it's tough on [52:24] [52:24] the early days it is very hard it's fun [52:27] [52:27] it is hard but I also think like I'm not [52:29] [52:29] so sure if I'm dying to go back to like [52:32] [52:32] having to pull out of scene here [52:34] [52:34] everything it's also nice when you have [52:35] [52:35] something to build on right good point [52:39] [52:39] um so obviously with experience you [52:42] [52:42] don't uh it the journey gets easier but [52:47] [52:47] not so much easier right so so linear [52:50] [52:50] was a different example so review was [52:52] [52:52] hard initially right two wasn't that [52:54] [52:54] hard finally I mean [52:57] [52:57] yes fair enough yeah it was hard all [53:00] [53:00] along uh but there's there's some [53:02] [53:02] valuable learnings but two [53:04] [53:04] great team we put together a great bunch [53:07] [53:07] of people it was hard things picked up [53:09] [53:09] yeah and you started building hopefully [53:11] [53:11] the next one you know there's enough of [53:13] [53:13] a you know pattern recognition bank [53:15] [53:15] that's been built up that could that I [53:17] [53:17] could I can I can rely on to make the [53:20] [53:20] next whatever it is uh fine you know so [53:23] [53:23] if you're looking for investors for your [53:25] [53:25] next venture you can come on Thursday [53:27] [53:27] when we do the pitch to investors yeah [53:29] [53:29] maybe you can be there I'm teaching your [53:30] [53:30] new idea I need to work on that uh [53:33] [53:33] significantly before I come come forward [53:35] [53:35] now uh we like it early [53:37] [53:38] last question [53:40] [53:40] um or combination of questions who's the [53:42] [53:42] best reference or person that has [53:44] [53:44] influenced you a best book best podcast [53:47] [53:47] okay let me start with podcasts so it's [53:51] [53:51] a podcast I'd say I I follow the [53:53] [53:53] huberman labs uh podcast uh I really [53:58] [53:58] value uh my the content on that uh [54:02] [54:02] that's one of my is up there I'd also do [54:04] [54:04] you know uh Financial Financial policy [54:07] [54:07] FP which is really good just to get you [54:10] [54:10] that's a podcast it's called Financial [54:11] [54:11] policy yeah a foreign policy not [54:13] [54:13] finished foreign policy it's pretty good [54:15] [54:15] it just opens your mind to uh what's out [54:18] [54:18] there from a micro standpoint using [54:19] [54:19] Trends so on so these are the two ones [54:21] [54:21] that I really follow [54:22] [54:22] from podcasts books I would say I got [54:26] [54:26] into The Hitchhiker's uh Guide to the [54:28] [54:28] Galaxy it's it's obviously fiction [54:30] [54:30] classic classic I haven't finished all [54:32] [54:32] of them so I'm the first I've got [54:34] [54:34] through the first three a couple couple [54:36] [54:36] left so that's been a really interesting [54:39] [54:39] read on how to sort of go through life [54:42] [54:42] and not take yourself too seriously so [54:43] [54:43] learning's there [54:45] [54:45] uh and then person so you know on the [54:48] [54:48] personal front it's uh I have a lot to [54:50] [54:50] thank my mother for so she's she's no [54:52] [54:52] longer with us so she was a big [54:53] [54:53] influence in my life early on and from a [54:55] [54:55] business context let's say you know [54:56] [54:57] learnings people I've worked with would [54:59] [54:59] you say or just you know someone you [55:00] [55:00] look forward to [55:01] [55:01] some preference for you that you learn [55:03] [55:03] from yeah so I'd say uh basos for his [55:07] [55:07] like Obsession when it comes to customer [55:10] [55:10] centricity and so on was uh [55:13] [55:13] is is someone I would really look up to [55:16] [55:16] in that sense [55:17] [55:17] um that that you know that Obsession on [55:19] [55:19] on creating a product that's great [55:20] [55:20] meeting people's needs and touching [55:22] [55:22] people's lives in that regard yeah some [55:24] [55:24] words no [55:26] [55:26] you know what you learn about preferred [55:28] [55:28] equity and well that happens everywhere [55:32] [55:32] right yeah it happens it's an expensive [55:35] [55:35] School expensive School uh no but for [55:38] [55:38] all that all said and done I think you [55:39] [55:39] know what they've done for the the [55:41] [55:41] ecosystem at that time they did that for [55:43] [55:43] Europe and Germany particularly yeah [55:44] [55:44] absolutely I mean indeed the internet [55:45] [55:45] they get applications they get a hard [55:47] [55:47] rap but you know there's [55:49] [55:49] a lot of a lot of businesses that come [55:51] [55:51] out of that system the linear Mafia if [55:53] [55:53] you will and a lot of stuff yeah so it's [55:56] [55:56] I have a lot of time you have a lot to [55:58] [55:58] thank for be thankful for for that [56:00] [56:00] experience so it's not a yeah [56:02] [56:02] uh and it's like in life right you meet [56:04] [56:04] all kinds of people uh some tougher than [56:07] [56:07] others some different it's a it's an [56:09] [56:09] area of experiences and you just [56:11] [56:11] basically have to take it for what it is [56:13] [56:13] thank you so much thank you very much uh [56:15] [56:15] it's just been a pleasure and uh yeah [56:17] [56:17] we'll follow your journey yeah [56:19] [56:19] foreign
Transcripción completa
did you meet with kolau not directly but with the rest of her team and this was quite a challenge because we moved ahead without let's say their blessing there were people who were fined yet really yeah there are people who find she's like as a Founder which is hard enough then again fighting against the police like on top of everything fighting against the market and fighting against the place it was challenging uh to say the least and then how did what happened with Robbie yeah exactly between the news it was recently in the news yeah so it's um it's still in in litigation so in the US in the US is [Music] engagement [Music] [Music] bienvenido [Music] daily welcome everybody I'm Bernard Ferrero today I'm with Jordan Romero how are you Jersey very good I'm with Kiran Thomas how are you kidding doing well thanks Kiran is a consultant initially then executive then entrepreneur yeah there was a period in between where it was also part of the founding team of uh which is today latam's let's say top five uh a general merchandise retailers in the world in the region called Lineo so I was one I was part of the founding team there as well so okay part of the journey okay so in in entrepreneurship you've participated in projects around Mobility with Rabbi yeah fintech with two and e-commerce with linear and e-commerce and you are from India originally that's correct so yeah my roots are there I was born and raised there uh so my formative years were living were there and then I after my education which is engineering degree in computer science I immigrated to the United States where I started working and got acquainted with what in the US so most of my uh life in the US was based in Chicago and the Chicago land area a little bit also in in the St Louis Minneapolis area for consulting-based project work somehow life brought you to Barcelona yeah life wrong you live here you're happily living for a while yeah yes near from where we're recording this very close by uh setting down Roots uh literally speaking so my uh uh two I have two kids they both go to school here they're growing up here trilingual obviously they've trilingual so Catalan in school uh Spanish at home with my wife and English with me okay yeah okay we'll talk about Ravi and and two which I think they're very interesting cases but maybe we can follow the chronological order from your Beginnings now as a studying computer science in India maybe you can share with us how how is environment in India to start computer science it's very well known for having great talent in computer science and great universities indeed yeah and and why did you emigrate why did you go out from India sure so um when I was in university uh in the in the late uh 90s early 2000s it was a boom time when you know the I.T Consulting uh phase of of uh of the industry so India was at the time uh servicing most of the West in terms of BPO so business process Outsourcing and so on a lot of Consulting work was coming and being done in the country India was going through a point a time when we were solving problems for the rest of the world rather than internal problems but that's not techno you talk about things more like accounting yeah business classes Insurance yeah call centers and also um development work right so okay a lot of enterprise software uh work was being done income on behalf of large Consulting companies the IBM's Accenture Deloitte so on and so forth so it was quite common to be you know campus recruited by national firms so deloittees Etc start in India and then Branch over get yourself a H1 Visa and go to the America and go to the US that was a difficult path so I had that option that's what I did it was the done thing one you know it just catapulted your career in many ways uh by being able to go there and being sort of let's say trained in a way to go and take on challenges in that market right so was it like your plan from early on like I'm gonna do these four steps so I can go to the US or it just kind of happened they tell you this is It's opportunity it's a bit of both so I had the opportunity and also had you know family there so it made the reason for me to go there a lot more on your ring so yeah so it was a mix of consequences right it was not and it was a time when it was the done thing not to say that doesn't happen now but now there's more of a homegrown industry than that you know is solving big problems in India this and people are finding that a lot more exciting and people stay in the country so it used to be more like the company and the capital is in the US or some other countries and then they hire labor talent in India yeah yeah and what you're saying is now there is more businesses in India hiding their talent locally and just selling their services abroad yeah so now there's a concept of building built in India built for the problems in India and Export those Solutions worldwide right which which makes sense in the past it was solving problems in the west exporting those solutions to third world countries and and developing countries and now there's a reckoning that you know there are real problems to be solved here there's capital in those markets of course some Capital comes from from from outside the country and this is much stronger value proposition really I think more than exporting the products is building the internal Market I mean it's a huge Market we're in Spain where 40 something million people and and many many companies are based on focus in the Spanish Market which doesn't make much sense but when you are 1.3 billion people then it makes sense and growing and growing with lots of opportunity to much of the West yeah and and presently with the current Administration uh that is so pro-business uh women of India I mean the current government in India is pro so pro-business uh has put a lot of foundational elements in growing the economy right from identity verification to imagine the scale of the challenge right when you're talking about 1.4 1.5 billion people being able to offer them uh you know fintech services like real uh you know there was an unbanked population of what you know 60 70 now that's being reduced uh so there's real value generation in that in in society in India that that's on you know that's coming at an unprecedented rate right so nothing has happened like that in the past so yeah so I studied Computing uh but always had let's say a flare or an interest in pursuing something on the edge between the intersection between business and and and the tax and Tech area so my career in that sense sort of weird off into the analytics area so that's what I first cut my feet doing in in the retail sector working for a large big box retailer called Office Max um in the Chicago Chicago land area so it was instrumental in their post merger integration structure yeah Wilson you know experience especially at scale so we're talking about uh at the time the operations were somewhere in the range of about 2000 stores across the country offline retail and its challenges when it comes to replenishment forecasting purchasing and all of that that led me into uh an opportunity in the career in the retail sector uh in Consulting and Accenture accenture's retail practice I did that for quite a few years and got there was management consulting or Tech Consulting a bit of both again so I was uh so I was I had a very unorthodox experience there as well so I was responsible for the client management of a very large uh retailer called Best Buy and the international expansion it was fantastic it was I was living in Mexico I was living in the UK so they were sending you to different places for this Consulting agreement so it was the same account but I was responsible for a significant piece of uh of the implementation and so on so I spent a better part of three years living out of my suitcase at that point in my life it was great I can't imagine doing that now and decided that you know the next stage of my life would be something in entrepreneurship building on on the experience I had 11 I mean God until that point and then was very fortunate to be make an entry into the e-commerce uh entrepreneurship side of things setting up uh lineal lineupont.com headquartered in Mexico which and expanding it into seven countries across Lata how did linear get started like who comes up with the idea recruits the founding team yeah how is the structure so because it's a bit of an unusual case yeah indeed so it's it's not entrepreneurship as you would as we would do it today where you're starting everything from scratch I mean it's something you can do starting of a boy band right it's kind of you bring together uh key players and you put them together give them Capital exposure and so on and so someone at Rocket said there is an opportunity in e-commerce in latam yeah Samus pitch was do you want to be um I recall this do you want to be uh sleeping under your desk as a banking executive in in in in in Investment Banking or working on the spam filter for for for Google or do you want to be creating the next Amazon in uh in Latin America right so interestingly enough that copy that from Steve Jobs no do you want to keep selling sugar water possibly the guy from Pepsi some iteration okay but nevertheless it's strong it works it struck a very uh strong chord with me so I joined uh Lineo like two two or three months in so I wasn't I didn't get the designation of co-founder so for three months I mean three months it's not so it's not very much but then you know you had you so I met uh so Andreas who is my co-founder at two um he was he was the founder and CEO at um at linear we had a call I was in Mexico he said come join me so I was one of the first let's say executive not executive but one of the leadership team members uh my rolly bald so this was my first experience in e-commerce building out things from scratch to I was what employee number 30 or 40 within the team uh rapidly growing at its peak we were about 1600 people expanding across the region very crazy yeah this is very hard to manage well it's internet model yeah the vertical growth sometimes vertical crash yeah usually many times right so yeah so we we experienced the ups and downs uh it was a great learning experience great incubated model in that you you you build a lot of skills you learn things really fast so yeah just fond memories great experience how far did it go like like before you left how big was linear so linear when I left we were operating in six or seven countries Spanish speaking excellent Marketplace or e-commerce so we pivoted into a Marketplace so initially in the first year it was you know procured by uh model uh in I think year two or one around then we pivoted into a Marketplace model yeah what happened with the company it's a exited so it's sold yeah it's old so Falabella which is a Chilean retailer uh but made an acquisition in 2018. if you sort of compared with capital raised and uh relative to let's say valuation valuation yeah it was it was an okay exit for the management team not so great but for growth investors who came in late with liquidation preferences it was good it was a huge lesson yeah that unfortunately had the same in the past right and that's that's that's and you were based where when this was happening I was based in Mexico City and I moved to Barcelona in 2016. um so after this experience after the leading experience moved to Barcelona correct yeah but before the acquisition so yeah I was there for four years and then I left um yeah missed the acquisition by like uh 18 months I think it was pretty it was pretty intense from what I hear so at that moment you you met pep Gomez yeah so I know that for for my entry into into Barcelona so I'd known him uh from some of the events in the in the startup space what events maybe people everybody's looking for a co-founder so where did you meet your co-founder uh so he was part of Numa I think it was yeah uh so they their own events their own events it was an incubator or what was yeah so it's part of uh she had to come to the podcast and tell us what Numa was yeah you should have him on of course uh so Numa was um I I believe I don't know if they're still around but that was it was a an offshoot of Mobile World Congress right so it was part of the mobile World fund they had some participation in that uh and it was an incubator uh so Madam at one of the events there had some other connections but the type of event where there's just drinks and some couple of talks or something and you just went there too no actually I had a interesting enough that it reminds me I had another connection to pep just through his um girlfriend at the time he's a friend of uh my wife's sister so it was a random personal connection random personal connection coupled with events and so on getting done uh say it was you know a consequence of the time uh pep broke the the idea creation and so on so he was like pretty clear he wanted to do this uh we met around the time when I was uh leaving prevalia and we were living and then you met this or you met this opportunity and then you left prevalia was it no it was the other way around so I I left pre-value okay and I I started at uh with review so you wanted to start a company or yeah yeah so I wanted to start something the timing was just brilliant like uh uh when I was having my going away party at prevalia I was already Robbie was running so yeah so I remember discussing the welcome party next day no there was a welcome party it was just me and exactly buy Scooters or whatever you do the first day of the company and a week later we were in so it was two two Founders yeah initially uh and then we brought on about six months later two more um again and Christina who basically joined us um to build out the engineering let's say in the China angle of Engineering in China so chief engineer and chief China Hardware it's a hardware yeah Chef hardware and your Chief product or head of problem yeah this product everything else yeah uh I was actually the CEO initially I really so when I started when we started pep was everything to do with regulatory uh legal and fundraising um I thought you were gonna say he didn't do that because it doesn't sound so much fun he did the regulatory legal and fundraising that was bad and I was running all things uh from a serious standpoint okay very soon I realized that this was a hairy animal I wasn't excelling at a job so we game took over from me so Gamers uh who came in as a CEO uh also founder you know you could call him the founder yes so did you call him a Founder yeah yeah okay yeah and what the founder is it Equity certain Equity a significant stake in the business for uh for all uh founders of course yeah we've seen Founders join Founders joint companies five years in yeah but sometimes they are actually Founders and they own a huge chunk and they actually get the company started there it's like it's such a strange concept yeah it's different for for everybody it has to make sense for the team it did it did right so because when guillam and Christina came into the business game came with like 10 years of experience living in China Hardware experience the connections on the ground we built a proprietary scooter from from scratch so what we had on the streets were not unique was unique it was not mass produced off the shelf like uh all the other brands were doing at the time was that a good idea in hindsight indeed because we were able to do it very very cost efficiently so we didn't raise a lot of capital but building your own Hardware is it cost efficient really so again when we say building in in our context it was having the right connections to a Syndicate of suppliers that have the capability to put something together relatively fast so you design it designed it and the parts are built you don't create your own battery and your own wheel obviously yeah but you need your own stock you need to make some some kind of upfront investment it's different that you have a service no I think plenty of competitors were working with xiaomi back then I think yeah indeed but when you compared what we put to Market yeah it was an advantage it was an advantage it didn't break all the time I remember as a user it was like a tank right if you recall it was uh and we still have I mean still a lot of them in in various uh inventory Depots around which which will be liquidated at some point but yeah so that was um so it was an advantage and we saw it uh early in the journey uh and we were able to do it pretty Capital efficiently without raising Millions like other players you might say you race so the initial initial something like when I when I was Operation involved we raised about in the first round about three and a half million and then another five so eight eight and a half million in equity and then really invest somebody from Tesla or something did I imagine the story so it wasn't exactly so it was one of the original board members of Tesla every house uh this investor called Simon Rothman who uh card is our first check actually [Music] yeah so you get three and a half then five four million you have the China person that knows the producers builds your own scooter you build an app yeah you view demand yeah we built our own uh firmware how does it started working everything what are the Milestones of Robbie yeah what do you think what do you do the first 12 months for example yeah yeah how far do you go um so we started I think in July of 2018. um by I think October November we had built the basic platform right so the app no app was just the icing on the cake so I'm talking about the iot okay wow so yeah the BMS the battery management system everything was was ready and this was like from scratch to from nothing to something right the first proprietary sorry the first prototypes we were testing in November and by first to second week of December we were able to put out 50 scooters in Barcelona and this was uh this was interesting because uh we obviously didn't there was a regular I mean there was a regulatory gray area uh we were able to explore it turns out it wasn't great eventually yeah yeah so uh but there were some workarounds we came out with the lock anchoring the scooter to bike bike racks and so on which actually helped keep theft damage and the littering problem address those things we were in a litigious process here in our Flagship Market which was unfortunate but you know we kept going to the city with the city uh did you meet with kolau uh not directly but uh with the rest of her team and this was uh quite a challenge because we moved ahead without let's say their blessing uh but as far as why did they you know why did they hate so much this kind of things well they still do right they still do yeah well look so I was rather so we were all very idealized right in in pursuing something like this okay we're gonna disrupt public Mobility uh we're gonna disrupt in a good way in a good way it can also mean yeah yeah but but in hindsight I don't so there are other markets like Saragosa where there is a real uh mobility issue public transportation is sparse if you go there at certain times of the day you can't find a cab there's there's this Motors and whatnot but there's nothing else in between at that time it was the case so there it made a lot of sense but in a city like Barcelona where you have um you know millions of tourists it is a public nuisance I give you that it is a public nuisance right so free floating uh it can create problems it it is yeah it does create problems and I'll be you know you have to be honest and acknowledge that so and especially around you know dense neighborhoods like the gothic and so on yeah it's not nice right so people zipping around these things um yeah things it hadn't been proven out uh there were there was a lot to be desired was there some specific incident uh no do you remember like somebody I don't know falling dying somebody's dying on a no not on so fortunately you know but there was one incident where someone was hurt uh but nothing no no fatalities as I recall as far as I was I was I was involved but what did the the city hall uh argument what was it so the argument was um this is not approved no one uh it's it needs there needs to be a proper process uh it needs to be evaluated in terms of safety in terms of all of that we went through the process of registering each one of these vehicles with the city hall there was a process that we that we that we fulfilled a new process because it was a new process a new process but we registered them just like all the other Mobility operators like the bicycles yeah so we had the motorbikes exactly we had the QR code and everything uh so we we fulfilled all those requirements but you know it's a political thing right so you can't influence it uh you you do your best you work around using the experience that we built here in Barcelona and and the and the uh the density and the number of rides um we were able to drive operational excellence in terms of building a capability of maintaining the fleet building Partnerships with you know 3pl's third-party Logistics providers uh building that capability and exporting it to other markets such as all of these other places that maybe eventually ended up operating in through public tenders so taking this experience building working closely with building a legal strategy having a very strong legal team that was enabling all of these other cities to you know come up with a public policy around Transportation participating in those rfps and building long-term relationships with those cities so it it to that end it really helped but it was it's a shame that we couldn't operate in your home City in the home City exactly but you know I mean it is a challenge I remember I was a heavy user of Ruby for a while because they were the fastest anything most available ways of transportation around me but I remember going to Paris with you actually uh in 2018 do you remember I was shocked like the the the the Seas of scooters Fallen everywhere in the middle of the of the sidewalks and same in London there was nothing compared to China and the bicycles but it wasn't a pleasant experience like you're in the center of Paris and my feeling is like what's all this crap here in the middle yeah right like that's that's that was my and I want tools like this but it is a challenge to the city no but there needs to be a way to solve it but a great point because what happened in Paris specifically citing this example they did a referendum right uh six months ago and and the citizens voted against removing so they want they want the scooters no they voted against suitors ah okay so they don't want anything yeah so they didn't referendum About Scooters yeah wow yeah [Music] it's great for haters but it says we can open the box of democracy now but the consequence is that you know Paris is not going to have scooters they know this sort of uh free-floating uh Mobility options is going to be gone bicycles bicycles will continue it's kind of weird no why they're not that different they have two wheels and the problem is the sidewalk no if they are feeling the sidewalk yeah no yeah the scooters right but in a dense City like Barcelona and Paris and so on where you just don't have the public infrastructure it's very hard yeah but for example Barcelona got the the circulation right like I think we are one of the fastest growing cities in Europe in number of uh bicycle Lanes I don't know how you call them yeah so that part I think we kind of got right the problem is where do you leave the stuff like you're not going to take it home when people live in tiny Apartments so it's a good idea to rent it and share it but then where do we put them very popular in Barcelona but for some reason scooters are very hated yeah but not only the Public Services also the private scooters are kind of forbidden or anything no no you have to go in particular places you have to wear yeah speaking you're not supposed to ride on um on the aceras so on the side yeah but but yeah practically speaking you see people zipping by you so there's a nuisance Factor right so I'm not surprised that there's been a huge backlash and so coming back to to rebi uh scooters were just one mode of Transport so we had bicycles for you foreign the plan obviously was to include other modes of Transport like Motors scooters did you get there uh eventually yes yeah okay yeah so since they disappeared from Barcelona I never knew yeah so I um did it so it was basically um a different kind of model a franchise model okay you know um franchisees use the platform to to basically offer their offerings so yes and and if there was not no regulation problem would it be a good business because somehow I don't know the the all these players that appeared they went dying one by one and yeah so you know there has to be some some problem so there's space so there's very few uh operators left from that original cohort of American companies right so like the limes and limes still is still one of the dominant players but practically gone uh and then in Europe you have uh the Swedish Warrior which is still got a dominant presence in the nodding Sierra tier and boy I think are emerged or something to actually in fact yeah so yeah they're they're still relevant uh and the vast majority of other players have disappeared right or practically disappearing so it's a tough model uh uh it's we had the right instincts to invest in in and build a capability ground up from the hardware and so on um so to that end while it lasted it was it was good um but it's it's the unit economics are very strong a very hard way because the cost to serve is is very is very high the logistics is not cheap so the cost is what uh 1000 Euros a scooter no no um so um yes but we were able to do it for significantly less less than a thousand yeah 500 more or less 500 scooter then there's a maintenance so the maintenance is very is is problematic so maintenance being recharging so if you have a replaceable replaceable batteries it drops significantly but that adds on a lot of cost and you need people actual humans who will change the battery around the city also operationally is expensive uh you need to move the actual scooters to the point because there's typically a start point and end point and they're not the same yeah yeah but that also depends on the usage no so the usage has a percentage of cost for repairing and recharging and redistribution right so ultimately it comes down to uh so we have to be able to redistribute the fleet uh to certain points in where there's demand is going to be right so if you take uh what happened let's say in the peak months between July to September eighty percent of the fleet would be in uh in the Benoit area so you need to move those things back to uh what does these people do they just stay in the beach uh or I suppose yeah so it's just congregation they just get drunk and stay there so it can be frustrating in that sense from a user perspective if you don't distribute uh so we we did a decent job but that was not cost efficient we didn't crack that model there were algorithms that incentivated that people would take yeah from one place to another yeah so we we did that uh but you know the start and stop was very frustrating right so we didn't have enough operational data to be able to really optimize those models to be able to drive real value because you know you one week you'd be on one week you'd be off uh this cat and mouse with a city which is frustrating it uh it didn't help uh so you mean start and stop in terms of Regulation yeah that the police would suddenly yeah stop people right I remember Cesar telling me like police is stopping people driving uh riding on a rebi or other as good there's suddenly one week it's like don't don't get on one or you might get in trouble and then next week he was okay and they would be fine if you were driving I never got one there were people who were fined yes really yeah there were people who find she's like as a Founder which is hard enough then again fighting against the police like on top of everything fighting against the market and fighting against the place it was challenging uh to say the least um anyway so ready was um a great experience in that so you you left after a couple three years something like that so yeah I uh two years in I left my operational role so I uh I exited I so it was also um the timing also had to do with when we went to the franchise model around the pandemics time frame uh I opted out and it was also a combination of factors right so Andreas the CEO and co-founder of two had come back from linear he was in Norway getting ready to start something up we had a couple of chats to build something that would become too was really interesting and just you know I'd like to touch upon this and it'll be a perfect segue to get into why two came about and what was the problem we were solving so in our experience at uh linear Lineo is a Marketplace uh Merchant right so we were selling stuff on behalf of merchants and about 20 of our clientele clients where business is making purchases on our platform and typically these businesses required to make or to make purchases on invoice right so with some deferred mode of payment some credit and as big as linear was it was not a core competency we could not credit on the right we could not have a verify identity issue invoices follow-up collections all of that it was a huge challenge and we were losing a lot of sales a typical experience of some of these customers would they would come into the you know checkout page and they'd they'd see pay with credit card pay with cash they pick up the phone call customer service how can I pay on invoice I want to buy 50 TVs uh you know pay in 30 days 60 days in 30 days we try to establish some of the sales would be loosen so that's the point the the the challenge that we are trying to solve or we are solving here today with two and you know that resonated really well with me early stage let's get this going working again with Andreas on on this was amazing so uh it was you know tough decision to make to leave rabi uh that was very understanding can you can you share with us um because this is something that happens in startups when founders start a company with all the dreams and illusion of what's going to happen and then at some point things go south or things don't go as expected and then they have this conversation yeah so how do you manage this conversation with your co-founders yeah so with a lot of uh guilt uh and uh and stress obviously um so it was a tough time for the business it was you know the pandemic was on uh the business was slowly getting back on its feet I had this thing uh this was precisely three years ago so September in 2020. um so yeah I I was clear in what I wanted and I was also uh at a point in my life uh where I wanted to put myself and my family forward right first the review experience was great and where I was within the company what I could offer in terms of regulatory uh aspects of things fundraising uh and so on I wasn't adding a lot of value there personally so it was a reckoning now look I could do better somewhere else or I could continue here and I think you know when I had that conversation with pep it was hard but he was understanding you know this is ultimately a where your heart is is what you do and I stayed on in a you know advisory capacity uh beyond that but I I I removed myself from a day-to-day um starting you know 2020 September October and then around January when things really started picking up with two I was fully out so fully out as in also selling you shares or you stayed a shareholder I stayed as a shareholder uh until um until the the acquisition uh by Seoul uh or House of lithium which was basically they let us use a at rebbe this was just after I I left so they were one of the biggest investors the Lead Series investor is the one that offered to acquire the company correct yeah that offered uh signed well yeah I mean that's something I wanted to ask about because for but but then in this series hey if there was a secondary and is where you left no I I didn't settle at the series a so I sold uh before before the acquisition just before the acquisition okay and then how did what happened with Robbie yeah exactly between the news here it was recently in the news yeah so it's um it's still in in litigation so in the US in the US uh because this is a Delaware Corporation and uh the last outcome was that you know it we need to basically go to trial again and yeah that's where it is so this house of lithium came to rabi and said I want to buy you or Robbie went to them and say we want to sell I'm not on on top of the details uh there but basically they were one of the investors right so lead investor with a with a significant stake in the business already prior to the acquisition and from what I understand their strategy was to build a constellation of Brands right so around probability uh battery management uh and so on and ready was fit into the the picture as one one piece of that puzzle uh and they had acquired another cost another company in the battery space uh and so on and this was basically the plan to float uh an entity that gets uh on the on the Canadian Stock Exchange So to that end the review deal would be you know review would be acquired wholly uh by house uh yeah like um you know cash to pay out the the equity holders uh and and some Surplus for for for some early for the management team or exactly and that was basically the team but it was a good a good outcome for the founders and for the investors if it had gone through from what I understand it would have been a fantastic uh outcome for uh the shareholders acquisition yeah because they and for the company that would survive yeah yeah but you know the way things ended up is that uh what happened what what's the Tipping Point so litigation is expensive but why is there litigation no what happened probably is that the market Fall so the world financial Market there's many things right so one is uh yes so the company needed a response right so either through an acquisition or through the private markets uh as a extension to the series A or B or whatever we have we had a term sheet that was executed and signed uh not term sheet a sale document everything done so the transaction the transaction was assigned typically in a transaction document like this you have like 30 days to wire the money and stuff like that a portion of the funds were wired as well a portion of the funds was wired yeah a small portion yeah so the deal was had happened in the second the second wire never came the The Joint statement the press release was will happen with them so there was a there was an article crunch everything yeah that's true so everything went out and then yeah it was like uh I suppose a Twitter Elon moment on their end um and they they've done their best to get out of it so they decided to walk back the acquisition yeah excited legally yeah and that's basically where we are today it's uh that sucks you have a Twitter I mean I don't lost yeah let's say no yeah so I don't know that I know don't know the document but depends on how it's written especially in the US well it looks quite effective explicitly said he doesn't want anything diligence like he signed the worst possible contract apparently yeah but it should be quite effective in the US maybe in Spain that could be two years but or more or more yeah so you know for practical purposes there is a There's Hope um yeah yeah I think you know that they're forced to pay and then but how can that we hope I mean the company cannot survive like people cannot stay waiting for money to arrive no that's true so things are uh where they are today because of that because of that reason yeah I'm sure there's an infinite detail right there the thing is you went then uh you met Andreas again uh with it was somebody you you liked when you worked with him and and you felt like that was a good opportunity for you um and and what and the beach was what you said before no solving this problem that you're covered in basically what is two we offer an API payment method for API based payment method for B2B so B2B specific you can simplify it by saying it's a buy now pay later solution for specifically for B2B so what that entails is we enable um businesses that make purchases so all people that make purchases on behalf of your business so let's take the use case of factorial purchasing computers from Apple or uh or Amazon right so you have an account a trade account with one of these companies that's a real case we do that yeah so uh and uh and two basically offers a fund fully funded invoice solution to Amazon to fund um the purchases on behalf of factory so we don't pay Apple you pay Apple correct and then we pay you correct and this is an API only so I didn't even know that you exist Apple provides this to us so it depends on the operating model and where we operate we are not a white label solution per se so we exist as a payment so the financing agreement is with you the the end exactly so we uh help the merchant delegate all of the collections uh the risk the the credit and the fraud risk to us so it's closer to Atlanta or an affirm yeah the difference is the buyer is specifically B2B exactly so it's a much larger what changes product space when the buyer is a B2B for from whose perspective from the business perspective yeah the risk is a lot harder to assess because you know you don't have uh credit bureau information so it's a capability to build that we we have now three years under our belt doing it in three markets do you have algorithms or data or something we've built when I put factorial ink which is not a real name that I put their company name then you know How likely you are to get the money back yeah exactly so we we built we've invested and make that happen um so we give you um a credit worthiness score and then you know right away whether you can continue with the purchase or not and in some cases the merchant has the capability to show whether the payment method is relevant for you or not they're factoring now so factoring so factoring happens in a post sale context where the issue or the invoice is created and then you sell the invoice so what we're doing is real-time decision making right so we're doing it at the point of sale so yes it is factoring but it's factoring with a Twist the invoice in the user experience though it's a much faster the risk ass salesman and everything it's the same thing is the seller no who decides to do that so I sell you something expensive you're going to pay me 90 days and I go to the bank and I say I want the money now and the bank gives it to me the seller no that's another thing that is factoring factoring is not a seller yeah that's how I understand factoring it's a seller who gets this so your account payables right so your account receivable you can sell your I want to get the money earlier exactly exactly well obviously at a cost for me so you partner with Apple no so that would be great uh we no so our uh so in Sweden we operate with uh net on net which is one of the largest uh e-commerce uh players in the region in Norway the authorized Apple distributor is uh office to as a payment method uh so we service everything from SAS consultancies physical Goods uh purchasing and uh and in the construction space as well so marketplaces are also an option are you judge who we charge the margin so no matter so it's it's it's exactly like offering uh later no so think of it like you have you're selling a product on your site right and you offer credit card as a payment method so you're basically we're we're basically the payment method instead of you paying stripe you're paying us and you have a parameter of better conversion exactly much higher conversion what are they paying for specifically for B2B right so so back to your case in linear so coming so when they wanted 40 TVs and they didn't want to pay up front they didn't buy if they lost their sales it's a lost lost sale opportunity that you that you that you don't lose um then the operational complexity right most businesses are not in the should not be in the business of credit underwriting Collections and so on right so it's operationally complex there's overhead that is outsourced to two so two basically does all of that on behalf of those customers so if the customer doesn't pay it's always your problem it's my it's our problem exactly so you're very motivated to do the correct underwriting exactly exactly not just for your customer but because otherwise you take this yeah we take the hit of course so this is a capability that uh what what is what's the price what's the interest rate so there's no interest so it's not interest rate based it's basically a transaction fee service yeah it's a transaction fee in interest so think of it I will convert it as an interest if I would be a seller so think of it as the it's on par with the transaction fee that you would pay strike or for an Amex transaction right so like a two each percent to each percent yeah okay on on a 15 to 30 day invoice so if if it's a different product which is basically installments which we could do anywhere between three to 12 months it will be higher and how do you collect the money how do they pay you um you cannot pay stripe no yeah exactly it's wire transfer why transfer or uh and then you have an army of collections agents that are calling um you know so we're pretty efficient so we're in the northern switch I guess yeah so we do have a small collections team which is like one or two people uh it's very small for a business that only does this basically yeah yeah and the UK as well um so it's basically UK should be maybe more challenging so our basically a Collections Unit is about three people but it's it's highly organized automated so our bank operations um yes uh there are it's a small it's a small percentage but you know in in this business what you do is you don't you build up you build up the confidence right so there are some first time there is there is first party fraud uh but it's a very small percentage we don't take big risks and there is an identity verification piece associated with with the buyer experience you don't take big marginal drift invoice by invoice but in some you're thinking another place yeah but it's Diversified right it's across Industries it's across multiple how much money is Lent out right now for example this is the number you track uh roughly is it like in the millions tens of millions so we're transacting in the almost double digits uh volume per month on a monthly basis so eight nine whatever seven eight nine million no slightly more than that okay we're on track to basically 2x uh 2.5 x what we did in 2022 okay the the demand is that growth is there and we're and you said Norway Sweden Norway Sweden and UK and the UK is a no-brainer I mean if you're giving money to the people that's always a man the question is how can you build a business a sustainable business sustainable business indeed so and do you go to SMB or you go to large Enterprise it's totally different risk so yes so we are we we had to start at the lower end which is small small and medium business the risk is there but you know if you build uh so think about it this way right so who's taking the risk today is the merchant if they don't offer any Services any any buy now pay later or let's say they are just extending invoice or net terms on invoice they're taking the risk the sales are growing and what they're doing is basically forwarding us good customers there's a need there's a digital good or bad customer good customer so the good customer they can do it themselves yeah but they're taking so nobody give good customer but there's a working capital issue right so if you if they're going to pay you in 30 days what we're doing is we pay you right away so there is a valuable position there okay there's no collections they don't have to have a team running after but why don't they give you the bad customers too if they get paid today sure of course we give us customers exactly so good about has to pay for the collection people the risk that you are taking and the whole business so it's a high volume business it's a high volume business it's like payments right payments is um it's a high scale business you have to you have to be operating you need to get to the billions yeah and that's for there to be a business yeah that's um that's the part we're on uh the trajectory of our own and uh so far so good so so and and you said you it raised the reason it raised money and yeah so we uh so we raised our initial round um in 2021 so a good time yeah so precede uh uh which was led by uh Sequoia and local Globe uh and Visionaries club and then we followed that up in the summer with a with a seed round and then a series a round uh we we closed it last October uh anymore yeah but you know it's uh the timing was uh could have been worse but we did we did well in that sense uh did you race in total so the most recent round was about 20 million uh USD so in total we're at about 28. the company legally what is it so we're headquartered and we're headquartered and Incorporated in Norway so it's Norway it's a Norwegian and the team so the team is distributed between uh Oslo which is where uh there's about 20 people there there's another 20 in London Sweden has a small presence about five or six people and we have a tech Outpost in in Glasgow uh so we built a small team there about 70 people and then our distributed Workforce across other other markets but that's a small smaller proportion of uh of employees or remote where do you see your future so um in the next three to five years being one of the largest B2B Payment Solutions uh with a huge presence in in the US just which is the next big market for us to capture um yeah so processing in in the billions and of course being contribution margin uh positive not profitable yeah that's uh that's the goal working towards that and yeah let's see so the Tailwinds are there you know their businesses need working capital relief and that's something we do really well and you roll specifically yeah so that's a vault uh again I've done many things at two so started in the product role uh transitioned into taking care of all things uh people and investor relations so in internal and external in that context today I'm in the process I I don't know if I mentioned it earlier so I'm in the process of transitioning out of an operating role at two um we'll do that over the next four or five months the reason being primarily I've spent three years being one of the key members of the team working remotely from Barcelona the company is at a stage where you know we require a physical presence in either Oslo or London for someone in my way I mean I'm very much for repeating yeah so why would you say it requires for me personally it would be uh for me to be more engaged to be on stuff on a day-to-day basis and I think you know you have a better velocity when it comes to decision making higher engagement so on um and for me it's very hard to do that uh from where I am here one one thought I mean obviously not to you because you've seen early stage many times but I think many people romanticize early stage and I've had many people that have been at larger startups and they say what they like is the early stage and then they go to the early stage and they cannot stand the uncertainty the chaos the lack of resources the scrappiness the constant fear of death so obviously you've seen that plenty of times yeah especially from private already exceptions it wasn't so dramatic as death but there were tough times right uh and yeah so your people romanticize it it's tough on the early days it is very hard it's fun it is hard but I also think like I'm not so sure if I'm dying to go back to like having to pull out of scene here everything it's also nice when you have something to build on right good point um so obviously with experience you don't uh it the journey gets easier but not so much easier right so so linear was a different example so review was hard initially right two wasn't that hard finally I mean yes fair enough yeah it was hard all along uh but there's there's some valuable learnings but two great team we put together a great bunch of people it was hard things picked up yeah and you started building hopefully the next one you know there's enough of a you know pattern recognition bank that's been built up that could that I could I can I can rely on to make the next whatever it is uh fine you know so if you're looking for investors for your next venture you can come on Thursday when we do the pitch to investors yeah maybe you can be there I'm teaching your new idea I need to work on that uh significantly before I come come forward now uh we like it early last question um or combination of questions who's the best reference or person that has influenced you a best book best podcast okay let me start with podcasts so it's a podcast I'd say I I follow the huberman labs uh podcast uh I really value uh my the content on that uh that's one of my is up there I'd also do you know uh Financial Financial policy FP which is really good just to get you that's a podcast it's called Financial policy yeah a foreign policy not finished foreign policy it's pretty good it just opens your mind to uh what's out there from a micro standpoint using Trends so on so these are the two ones that I really follow from podcasts books I would say I got into The Hitchhiker's uh Guide to the Galaxy it's it's obviously fiction classic classic I haven't finished all of them so I'm the first I've got through the first three a couple couple left so that's been a really interesting read on how to sort of go through life and not take yourself too seriously so learning's there uh and then person so you know on the personal front it's uh I have a lot to thank my mother for so she's she's no longer with us so she was a big influence in my life early on and from a business context let's say you know learnings people I've worked with would you say or just you know someone you look forward to some preference for you that you learn from yeah so I'd say uh basos for his like Obsession when it comes to customer centricity and so on was uh is is someone I would really look up to in that sense um that that you know that Obsession on on creating a product that's great meeting people's needs and touching people's lives in that regard yeah some words no you know what you learn about preferred equity and well that happens everywhere right yeah it happens it's an expensive School expensive School uh no but for all that all said and done I think you know what they've done for the the ecosystem at that time they did that for Europe and Germany particularly yeah absolutely I mean indeed the internet they get applications they get a hard rap but you know there's a lot of a lot of businesses that come out of that system the linear Mafia if you will and a lot of stuff yeah so it's I have a lot of time you have a lot to thank for be thankful for for that experience so it's not a yeah uh and it's like in life right you meet all kinds of people uh some tougher than others some different it's a it's an area of experiences and you just basically have to take it for what it is thank you so much thank you very much uh it's just been a pleasure and uh yeah we'll follow your journey yeah foreign